Kirkclaugh 1
Image by rockartwolf
Kirkclaugh

Rock Art in walls

I can't let that pass - although I probably should.

Nobody knows much about Rock Art, that is probably its main attraction. And you were the guy that supposedly surveyed ten cupmarked stones at the Knar, yet only found three of them and then classed them as 'natural cupmarks', when the quarry they clearly came from was just a hundred yards away and where there was identical rock, but without any cupmarks at all. (Which effectively undermined everything you surveyed - if you were so wrong there what about other sites you'd seen). And I was working just half a mile away, with a cellphone in my pack.

SL, I did offer to visit the Knar, but it got passed to someone who lived a little closer. If it’s the person I think it is, they're pretty good at geology and determining the likelihood of what 'is' and 'isn't' rock art (as much as you can). Sorry if you feel a little let down by their opinion, but finding & recording 10 rocks would take up a day and a half, & there’s little point if you believe them to be natural (unless previously recorded). There’s plenty in the Beckensall Archive that have had 'probably natural' slapped on them during the project, so don’t feel victimised.

FW, sorry for the above comment, you just rub me up the wrong way sometimes.