Kirkclaugh 1
Image by rockartwolf
Kirkclaugh

Rock Art in walls

FourWinds wrote:
Hob wrote:
FourWinds wrote:
Who would try and split a stone into two thin slabs like that?
Especially when there was a whole pile of much more portable, useable stone right next to it.

I think I can more or less accept that some of the oval cups are the real deal, but still have a problem with the ones Stonelifter labels 'canoe shaped'. As I've said elsewhere on this thread, some of those quarry marks may be ancient, but they're nowt to do with cups marks per se.

Each example on its own merit I would say. Some are. Some ain't.
why post some that aint then? I think what you're proving here FW is that you know little about RA and even less about quarrying.

Hob wrote... "reminds me of the hours of endless fun I've had staring at the natural patterning caused by fossilised mangrove roots in Wiltshire stones, then concocting half-baked thories about how the signifiance of natural holes in stone are related to the meaning of cup-marks."

Could this be the explanation for the curious marks on this stone?

http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/site/6611

Jim.

I can't let that pass - although I probably should.

Nobody knows much about Rock Art, that is probably its main attraction. And you were the guy that supposedly surveyed ten cupmarked stones at the Knar, yet only found three of them and then classed them as 'natural cupmarks', when the quarry they clearly came from was just a hundred yards away and where there was identical rock, but without any cupmarks at all. (Which effectively undermined everything you surveyed - if you were so wrong there what about other sites you'd seen). And I was working just half a mile away, with a cellphone in my pack.