Kirkclaugh 1
Image by rockartwolf
Kirkclaugh

Rock Art in walls

SL, I did offer to visit the Knar, but it got passed to someone who lived a little closer. If it’s the person I think it is, they're pretty good at geology and determining the likelihood of what 'is' and 'isn't' rock art (as much as you can). Sorry if you feel a little let down by their opinion, but finding & recording 10 rocks would take up a day and a half, & there’s little point if you believe them to be natural (unless previously recorded). There’s plenty in the Beckensall Archive that have had 'probably natural' slapped on them during the project, so don’t feel victimised.

FW, sorry for the above comment, you just rub me up the wrong way sometimes.

Rockrich wrote:
FW, sorry for the above comment, you just rub me up the wrong way sometimes.
Don't worry about it. I'm well aware of my limitations in a great many fields.

[Edited to remove my snide, unecessary comment. Sorry.]

I'm sorry for the case of mistaken identity - I'll pull the pins out of that wax doll I made of you. There's a lot of small stuff at the Knar and it is worth a visit. There was a long cairn there that was entirely made of naturally cupmarked stones, but it's been ground up, and there is another place where natural cupmarked stones have been collected and perhaps arranged, but.

The big stuff is in the main South Tyne Valley but is mainly altered or flat in the ground. The place to start is Holymire and spotting the remains of the large circle from the railway line - it hasn't even been paced out yet. I was more than disappointed with the rock art survey at the Knar as there'd been protracted correspondence with the coordinator, over months, and I'd made a pretty good map of the fields with the stones marked. Onward, onward; my next plan is to get one of these fossilised hailstone rocks to that conference in Dublin and to see if they'll set up a 'make your own cupmark' table with a slab of damp modelling clay on. (The early pottery was made by coiling rolls of clay which could possibly feed back into the carved spirals somehow).

Rockrich wrote:
... but it got passed to someone who lived a little closer. If it’s the person I think it is, they're pretty good at geology and determining the likelihood of what 'is' and 'isn't' rock art (as much as you can).
The cupmarks are identical to the ones on this stone ( http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/post/15000 ) - which have Mr Beckensall's seal of approval. And I mean identical in the sense of 'exactly the same'. The rocks at the Knar are a very soft sandstone - mother of coal - and the seashore rock is a very dense grit but the marks themselves are indistinguishable. Which, as I say, calls into question a whole load of other results.