The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   Sea Henge Forum Start a topic | Search
Sea Henge
Re: Sea burial
76 messages | Lock Topic
Select a forum:
Resonox wrote:
tjj wrote:
StoneGloves wrote:
Goldsworthy couldn't build a copy of one of the houses at Skara Brae because he's not a skilled drystone waller - he's a garden waller. If you look at his sheepfold video you can see him in action - it's appalling. I am embittered as I was the original sheepfold as sculpture person - and he simply nicked it. I did offer to teach him walling - there was no reply. Most of his rearranging nature, as art, is nicked from Japanese artists - allegedly - and what is more sad is that he has used copyright law against imitators to protect his work. Moron is probably an incorrect term, as his intellect is developed well beyond a 10 - 12 year old, and I should perhaps have used the word 'nitwit'. At least his stonework won't last, as it's all wrong. I see the general enthusiasm for his work as yet another sign of there being 'no hope for the human race'. Check out Rembrandt or Gaugin, Hepworth, Rie - he doesn't reach their ankles...


An interesting post Stonegloves - you obviously have subjective experiece of Andrew Goldsworthy's work whereas I knew little about him until now. Prompted by your reference, I have been looking at his work and am bowled over by its beauty and 'transience'. I like that he works with nature, takes photographs and lets his work return to nature. Your use of words like 'moron' and 'nitwit' puzzled me but ultimately proved positive as I've discovered a wealth of creative talent to enjoy.


I'm a bit confused by these posts....I'm assuming(feel free to correct the assumption).....that,Stonegloves is proclaiming Mr. Goldsworthy's work as infantile and derivative in the most negative of terms....yet tjj finds the post positive and proclaims Goldsworthy as creative and talented.....is there a middle ground??
I appreciate that two people can have varying and even opposing views...but I can't see how the twain meet here......enlighten me before the pain-killers kick in please.



I was taught that if you can't say something nice about a person you shouldn't say anything at all. You keep the peace that way.


Reply | with quote
Posted by Sanctuary
27th January 2011ce
23:56

In reply to:

Re: Sea burial (Resonox)

1 reply:

Re: Sea burial (moss)

Messages in this topic: