The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   Midsummer Hill Forum Start a topic | Search
Midsummer Hill
Re: Scrub clearance on Scheduled monuments
16 messages
Select a forum:
moss wrote:
http://www.themodernantiquaria[...]04836/news/midsummer_hill.html

Well if you read the link below and the news on 'scrub clearance' on the banks of the Midsummer Hill fort, you come to a dilemma, tree roots disturbing archaeological remains should be cut down (or should they?) unfortunately there is the mess and destruction that the use of heavy machinery brings in its wake destroying ecological balance....
Most of us have seen bulldozed barrows, and Old Sarum had 'scrub clearance not so long ago.
Well, my heart is always with the trees and the wildflowers, the gentle dissolution of nature through the centuries, and of course the glorious show of bluebells which may come back but I doubt it, those machines ruin the soil structure, much better to use hand tools and horses to haul out the felled trees.
Conservation what does it mean? was Penwith moor actually conserved by the introduction of long horned cows under the auspice of the national bodies who are supposed to protect our heritage but they seem to have enclosed the moor with fences and structures to 'allow' people access.

Anyway, bluebells versus archaeology, or the indifferent hand of man when he supposedly steps out to protect our heritage!




http://sulismanoeuvre.blogspot[...]2012/02/midsummer-murders.html


A strange dilemma indeed..should we allow nature to "destroy" sites or should man do it by destroying nature? I'm not exactly a tree-hugger but nature gets my vote every time. Are they being cleared to allow more public access? Well we have discussed it until we are blue in the face...the public (often) just want these sites as nice backdrops to their holiday snaps..."Oooh look at little Kiaora and her brother Mivvi climbing on the stones our ancestors put up...get a film of it...plus if they fall off it's £250 from You've Been Framed!"
One way of looking at it is..if these sites were created to venerate, enhance, embrace or even defy nature. Is it fitting that nature gets the final say...just my take.


Reply | with quote
Posted by Resonox
27th February 2012ce
09:01

Messages in this topic: