The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   Castlerigg Forum Start a topic | Search
Castlerigg
Re: Castlerigg desecration and vandalism
76 messages
Select a forum:
grufty jim wrote:
moss wrote:
Its a bit much that our sites are being desecrated by people from another country, how would they feel if we did the same in their country I wonder.

That was ironic, right? The history of colonial powers tends not to be filled with respect for the sacred sites of the colonised. I find it mind-boggling, for instance, that despite repeated protests from the Greek government, you still need to travel to London to view many of the statues from the Parthenon. And the looting of Egyptian antiquities remains one of the great cultural crimes of modern history.

More recently, and in a more general sense, one only needs to look at Macchu Picchu to see the effect of (mostly European and American) tourists on the sacred sites of other lands.

Of course, none of this lessens the desecration or vandalism of sites closer to home (by natives or by visitors) one single jot. But it's worth bearing in mind that the Guatemalan in question was merely carrying on a rich tradition practiced, sadly, by many.


All of that is of course true, and you are probably right to say we should look at what we have done in the past before pointing fingers at others.
Macchu Picchu is slowly being destroyed by tourists from all over the world, the Greek government have just built a new museum to house the statues from the Parthenon and lets hope they get them back.
Looting of sites is carried on by invading armies (Iraq), though also the local people are systematically digging up stuff to sell - the morality of each and every case has to be looked at individually.
The people to blame in this instance are the host organisation who allowed it to happen, they surely would have known that lighting of fires in stone circles is not on. The Guatemalans have their own traditions and were probably unaware of the uproar it would cause, so probably no blame there.

Edit; Got to come back on this one ;) googling there are pages of Mayan fire Ceremonies - mostly in other countries - even at the Glastonbury Festival, so what are we really looking at? A rebirth of ancient traditions or, a new age idea being touted around?


Reply | with quote
moss
Posted by moss
9th July 2008ce
13:58

Messages in this topic: