I'm sorry

close
more_vert

I really dont understand the repeated view being expressed on this board, that a millionaire should not be entitled to claim expenses.
Is this confined to politicians..or should it apply to all people in public service - the police, teachers etc?
Should millionaires be asked to work for free? or work expense-free?
Perhaps we should try an recruit more and more millionaires into public service, working for free, to help us get public sector spending back under control.

geoffrey_prime wrote:
I really dont understand the repeated view being expressed on this board, that a millionaire should not be entitled to claim expenses.
I can't speak for anyone else, but my problem is not with a millionaire claiming expenses, but with a millionaire claiming expenses out of the public purse while insisting that taxes are too high because inefficient public services are frittering away resources unnecessarily.

Just before this expenses furore kicked off, the tory mantra was all about "expenditure restraint" when it comes to public money.

George Osborne made a remarkable statement just over a month ago, for instance. He called for a reassessment of the pay deals that had been negotiated for teachers, nurses and police -- suggesting that it might have been OK for them to expect above-inflation increases during times of economic boom, but:

"Public sector pay needs to reflect the prevailing economic conditions. We need to look at these three pay deals the government came up with. They may be very inflexible at a time when the economic conditions are changing very quickly." (source)

I don't have an argument with that statement, taken at face value. If a nation sees a significant drop in available tax-income, then expenditure will eventually need to reflect this.

But the same people preaching restraint for those paid £30k, are busy picking up £100k paycheques and wondering how best to flip their unnecessary second home in order to avoid capital gains tax.

George Osborne, for instance, remortgaged his house (i.e. took a big lump sum from the bank in return for an increase in mortgage payments) then flipped the house so that the taxpayer paid the increased mortgage.

That's known as milking the system. And milking the system while insisting that everyone else exercise restraint, is hypocrisy bordering on corruption.

geoffrey_prime wrote:
Should millionaires be asked to work for free? or work expense-free?Perhaps we should try an recruit more and more millionaires into public service, working for free, to help us get public sector spending back under control.
Sorry if people seem a bit irrational on the subject of MPs expenses Geoffrey. Maybe they've got too sensitive lately.

They are so silly. It isn't as if an MP, knighted by her most gracious majesty and Chair and Director of banking, oil, hotels, textiles, pharmaceuticals and venture capital companies has just been exposed as having claimed and received £1,650 to buy a floating island for his fecking ducks!