close

I won't be buying a poppy. I haven't bought one for about 15 years. My reason is that up until then my dad got annual help from the Earl Haig Fund - he was a POW for 5 years in WW2.

It'd be something like food vouchers for Christmas, that sort of thing.

Suddenly he got a knock back letter reminding him of his lowly rank (conscription, just a regular), that those 'higher up' than him needed help, deserved it more (as diplomatic and bullshitty as is possible), and that funds were there to help 'all of our soldiers involved in all conflicts', which means Sadaam really was the new Hitler.

Bollocks.

I'm pretty sure there aren't many old dudes left from those times, I bet there weren't even that many then.


I don't begrudge the old guys their memories - course I don't, but I bet hardly anyone realises just how manipulative and cynical this whole 'fields of Flanders' imagery is now.
It's become a brand.

They can shove their poppies right up their arses (even tho they've got plastic stems now, not those sharp pointy ones).

x

My Grandad was helped a great deal by these people, and no, he wasn't high up the ranks.
They do a fantastic job and help a great deal of people. I imagine that the reason they don't have enough cash to help all is the fact that many people don't by the poppy pins and that means there just isn't enough to go round. Although, that is a terrible shameful thing that happened to your family, buying a pin will, in a small way, help it to not happen to others.

sermon over!

The Earl set up his fund to help ex servicemen from all confilicts. This mission statement is still applied today. He set it up in 1921, so using your logic, anyone from WW2 shouldn't benefit as much as WW1 victims anyway.

"I don't begrudge the old guys their memories - course I don't, but I bet hardly anyone realises just how manipulative and cynical this whole 'fields of Flanders' imagery is now.
It's become a brand.

They can shove their poppies right up their arses (even tho they've got plastic stems now, not those sharp pointy ones)."


Thats just offensive vitriol, which I don't fully understand. Whats become a 'brand' exactly?

As Captain Beefheart says:
I cry but I can't buy
Your Veteran's Day poppy
It don't get me high
It can only make me cry
It can never grow another
Son like the one who warmed me my days
After rain amd warmed my breath
My life's blood
Screamin' empty she cries
It don't get me high
It can only make me cry
Your Veteran's Day poppy

I think your getting a bit confused. I don't see that by buying a poppy as a charitable act I am somehow implicitly offering political support for a modern conflict?
And I have bought a poppy, by the way.