Stonehenge and its Environs 134
Image by RiotGibbon

goffik wrote:
Anyway. That's it, really: Could it be that the bluestones were already an existing stone circle that were uprooted and moved to Stonehenge?
That's a big bit of what Darvill's been looking at. He has looked at where the stones came from in the landscape, and how they are arranged at Stonehenge.
(Bear with me here as I can't remember it all) Even with the various re-erections of the blue stones it seems that their position at Stonehenge correllates with which bit of landscape they came from.
There are also apparently similaritys in bluestone arrangements at Stonehenge and Bedd Arthur.
I heard this from Darvill's own mouth at a talk in February but forgot to take any note making equipment with me!

This is getting more and more exciting as a theory.

The idea that the bluestones were a pre-existing circle has been mooted before - and makes more sense than the reverse IMO but I seem to recall a geologist saying they all came from widely spread strata - is that correct?

One interesting effect of the theory is that it throws the glaciation one out of the window of course.

Another is that the sarsens are of secondary importance maybe, and are just there for show! Actually Goff, as a well groupie maybe you'll empathise with that - they're unlovely, a bit crass and maybe just there to provide an impressive setting to the really important bit - which is exactly what the Victorians did to a lot of sacred wells...

Bedd Arthur is of course the pearl that links the bluestones of Carn Meini to Stonehenge, a similar horseshoe arrangement, and one other of course, the 'stone river' that runs so dramatically below Meini. One other factor that makes a strong 'ancestral' link is the smaller natural stone carns that look like neolithic longbarrows, and also, though I never investigated it but took a long distance photo, was a ridge with a line of stones making their way down the ridge..thats where I got my 'teeth' imagery. The creative act of looking at a sacred landscape can easily be visualised here....

And I forgot to say that if we could get rid of all the modern day paraphenalia round Stonehenge, and viewed it as something that amassed its history over centuries with all the barrow cemeteries round it, the truth might become clearer ;)