Stonehenge forum 180 room
Image by Chance
close

Just back from the hols, and catching up on some of the discussions -- God knows how many posts about "The Bluestone Enigma". As the author of said outrageous book, which so many people seem to find threatening, can I say "Thanks" to those who have read it and who have encouraged others to do the same? A great deal of the debate seems to revolve around points which are actually covered in the book -- too many points to list here. I'll deal with just one point. Somebody said they had looked at the "Bluestone Enigma" web site and at the PR and reviews which I used as publicity -- and that the "hype" had been a bit of a turn-off. OK -- point taken. But can I just make one point here? Does said critic realise just how difficult it is to get a "radical" book like this taken seriously by the archaeology establishment? The senior archaeologists who have worked at Stonehenge are so seriously entrenched in their views (and are so influential) that they cannot accept alternative views. And because they control the agenda and the media, it has been virtually impossible to get the book reviewed or taken seriously. Only one archaeology journal has reviewed the book, and even that review was accompanied by a "health warning"!! Pathetic. Why are these guys so scared? So the reality is that if one takes the risk of publishing a book like this, and putting good money into it, publicity is the only means of making you guys -- and the members of the public -- aware of its existence. So I don't apologize for the hype -- the alternative would have been to publish the book quietly, without telling anybody, and hope that somebody, somewhere, might notice it. Commercial reality, folks.
....... and by the way, I still have that free book offer for anybody who is prepared to stick a review on Amazon. Details here:
www.brianjohn.f2s.com/enigma1.html
I'll take the risk that some people will post crap reviews. Can't be fairer than that......

Yes, I may have a go at a review - will need to make an account at Amz first, but. I have sufficient 'evidence' to discredit many of the prominent members of the archaeology community, but nobody wants to know about it! The edifice of archaeological belief is very rigid but this rigidity should also imply brittleness. No doubt there will be a significant paradigm shift sometime - though it may be a long time - the contributors to this board are, in the main, subscribers to that world view. I'd better get reading that excerpt chapter...

mountainman wrote:
....... and by the way, I still have that free book offer for anybody who is prepared to stick a review on Amazon. Details here:
www.brianjohn.f2s.com/enigma1.html
I'll take the risk that some people will post crap reviews. Can't be fairer than that......
I'll have a go Brian, although the offer says this winter.... is it still valid?

Hi Brian -
Send me a review copy and I'll gerrit published with Amazon + a few other places. If it's good, I'll tell you it's good. If it's crazy, I'll tell you where it's crazy. If it's right - I'll tell you it's right; and if it's wrong...well, you know what I'll tell you. Can't say fairer than that can we!? Some archaeo-mythics are flawed; but some alternative archaeo-mythics are flawed too. Being someone who's walked amidst both these and other arenas, I reckon I'm more 'qualified' than those who just take their time in one just compartment. Email me for mi details.
Cheers - Paul

I'm more at ease with the honest, frank and open bluestones.

Breaking news from British Archaeology:

New Stonehenge Bluestone Mystery
The theory that almost all the Stonehenge bluestones came from the Preseli Hills in Pembrokeshire, accepted by most archaeologists since first proposed in 1920, is wrong, say two geologists. Rob Ixer and Richard Bevins have studied thousands of rock specimens from recent excavations at Stonehenge. They conclude that many bluestones came not from Pembrokeshire, but from a far wider area, perhaps north Wales (Snowdonia, the Llyn Peninsula and Anglesey), or even beyond. The well-known spotted dolerite is a Preseli rock, they say – but the likely source was not Carnmenyn (where archaeologists have recently claimed to have found quarries) but nearby Carngoedog.