Orkney forum 49 room
Image by wideford
close
more_vert

Totally disagree Moss .Greater understanding is more likely to lead to greater appreciation .What was previously considered mundane or dismissed , from members of our own species to all other species , from large monuments to the piece of bone in a cist ,to the dirt around the cist , all now more generally given a respect unthinkable even a few decades ago .

The source of our aesthetic appreciation/joy of phenomena , e.g. stars or ancient monuments or collectively is due to their presence but the quality of the experience is due to our filtering of the experience . Others may be offended by the monument , seeing it as an example of pagan beliefs or an obstacle to provision of much needed food or homes . Our contemporary understanding (huge distances , possible other inhabited worlds , not believing they influence our lives etc ) of the stars would underpin a different experience from someone who would have perceived them as having an impact on their lives . Seeing a comet over Stonehenge would not be a delight if you thought it would bring bad luck .

There is a reason why stones exist. There's actually is a reason for them, not just speculating. Mystery is for mystery. Facts are a different matter. which is why we should find out why they existed in the first place.

I think ceremonial - like churches.

Take yourself back to 5000 years ago. What would you do? No historian has the answer. Just exist I guess, which is what we are doing right now!

I'm looking for questions, not for answers.

Like, why? And does it really matter? Religion is for the dumb. Community?

[quote="tiompan"]Totally disagree Moss .Greater understanding is more likely to lead to greater appreciation .What was previously considered mundane or dismissed , from members of our own species to all other species , from large monuments to the piece of bone in a cist ,to the dirt around the cist , all now more generally given a respect unthinkable even a few decades ago ."

Well I knew we would disagree, and no I am not standing in the way of education though it has a lot to answer for...... the truth of the matter is that we only take a little of the picture from the archaeological ground, the essential life and spirit is dead, and we fill in the corners with speculation.


Subjectively I would be delighted to see a comet, and how many people through the ages will also have taken pure delight and awe in the stars and comets. I truthfully don't see any other person as different from myself. Anyway my favourite poem on Stonehenge which to me sums up the mess we seem to find ourselves in when we come to interpretation of these enigmatic stones Stonehenge which actually has the 'wow' factor though severely disrupted by all those 'educated' people ;)

A Game of Henge - Stonehenge

Phillip Gross

A game of Henge, my masters?
The pieces are set. We lost the box
with instructions years ago.

Do you see Hangman? Or
Clock Patience? Building bricks
the gods grew out of? Dominoes?

It's your move. You're in the ring
of the hills, of the stones, of the walls
of your skull. You want to go?

You want out? Good - that's
the game. Whichever way you turn
are doors. Choose. Step through, so...

And whichever world you stumble into
will be different from all the others, only
what they might have been,
you'll never know.

I agree with your well argued rationale Tiompan but on the other hand do get what Moss was saying. Last night an old friend (now on FB) posted an unspectacular shot of the moon with Venus also just visible in the shot. He accompanied his photo with some complicated astronomical calculations ...
I also had been looking at the moon (and Venus) earlier in the evening and greatly appreciated what I saw without possessing the in-depth astronomical knowledge my friend has.

Edited:(was waffling)