Orkney forum 49 room
Image by wideford
Orkney

Mess/Mass/Maes/May

close
more_vert

A problem, pointed out to me by Sigurd Towrie.

"Maeshowe is a later name for the site, which supplanted Orkahaugr during the earldom or later."

"It makes no sense for a Celtic name to supplant a Norse name, in an area where the language was a derivative of Old Norse and particularly given
the fact that practically all our placenames have a Norse origin"

One thing that springs to mind about his point though - is it possible that "Maeshowe" was an older name for the site, that continued in use among the population throughout the Norse period, with the Norse name "Orknahaugr" being almost an official name that was used pretty much exclusively in writing? The same way you'll see "Spey Valley" written, but everybody still actually calls it "Strahspey" (not a great example, as "Strathspey" means "Spey Valley" - but the point is that the place has two distinct names, one you'll pretty much only see written, and one you'll pretty much only hear people say).