Saith Maen forum 1 room
Image by postman
close
more_vert

I reckon the primary factor why we regard extreme natural features - mountain tops etc - as 'special' is that we no longer, in general, live in close proximity on a day to day basis. Industrialisation, of course, brought most of us into an urban environment, the Victorians thus regarding a visit to such landscapes as an escape from the squalor we created. Needless to say the people 'left behind' didn't see it that way. I've talked to farmers who can't see how anyone could regard Cadair Idris as beautiful... having seen it every day of their life, a vision they equate only to hard work.

In many respects the relatively low altitude of UK mountains is irrelevant - just means they are older - and people die upon them regardless, in all seasons - for example an SAS man last time I took my niece up the Brecon Beacons. Our weather, in general, is much more changeable and unpredicatble than other countries. I hold our high places in awe, and see no reason why our ancestors shouldn't have done so, too. How would they have explained peels of thunder echoing around a cwm, something which scares the living daylights out of me who supposedly knows the cause? In short extreme places cause extreme emotions.

GLADMAN wrote:
I reckon the primary factor why we regard extreme natural features - mountain tops etc - as 'special' is that we no longer, in general, live in close proximity on a day to day basis. Industrialisation, of course, brought most of us into an urban environment, the Victorians thus regarding a visit to such landscapes as an escape from the squalor we created. Needless to say the people 'left behind' didn't see it that way. I've talked to farmers who can't see how anyone could regard Cadair Idris as beautiful... having seen it every day of their life, a vision they equate only to hard work.

In many respects the relatively low altitude of UK mountains is irrelevant - just means they are older - and people die upon them regardless, in all seasons - for example an SAS man last time I took my niece up the Brecon Beacons. Our weather, in general, is much more changeable and unpredicatble than other countries. I hold our high places in awe, and see no reason why our ancestors shouldn't have done so, too. How would they have explained peels of thunder echoing around a cwm, something which scares the living daylights out of me who supposedly knows the cause? In short extreme places cause extreme emotions.

As ever, a great piece of writing Gladman, plenty to think about.
Edited: 26/2/11

GLADMAN wrote:
In many respects the relatively low altitude of UK mountains is irrelevant - just means they are older - and people die upon them regardless, in all seasons - for example an SAS man last time I took my niece up the Brecon Beacons.
The reason for the death of the SAS chap this year was due to exhaustion ,thats what the Brecon Beacons are used for , a bit of rough country where you can be pushed to your limits , running with 44 lb kit etc . Brecon is not viewed as a mountain survival or training ground purely a place to get fit physically and mentally The mountain training by the SAS is done in Alpine Europe .With the exception of some Scottish areas in winter conditions we don't really have the mountaineering experience here .