Maeshowe forum 16 room
Image by Hob
close
more_vert

>but that doesn't mean that the indigenous people were exterminated there or anywhere else<

>so i still have to go with the possibility of a friendly and gradual adoption of Viking culture<

Both of the above I am inclined to believe in general terms but
I also believe that for whatever reason, in the case of Orkney, the indigenous Picts were subject to ethnic cleansing.

I can think of no other reason why 99% plus of place names in the Orcades are of Norse origin.

In the Americas and Australasia, for example, although a good deal of genocide took place in the colonization of these lands by Europeans there are still a vast amount of place names attributed to the language of the indigenous people. In the case of Orkney this has not happened. There is a complete lack of anything not of Norse origin. This is the only place in these islands that this has happened. I can see no other reason for this than there were none of the original habitants left on the Orkneys to pass on local information.

However, I am open to reason, and would welcome suggestions as to how this could have come about without a mass annihilation of the local inhabitants.

FTC

there's also another question though - were there any Picts in Orkney when the Vikings settled?

some of the sagas say that Orkney was deserted when the Vikings arrived, which would certainly account for the complete lack of Pictish placenames. I really don't buy the annihilation theory, and to be honest I'm not sure about the integration theory either. but if the natives left before the Vikings arrived (or soon after) then we wouldn't expect to see Pictish names in Orkney. Pictish artefacts found in Norse settlements could of course be plunder or traded goods from other sites

Cheers
Andy

One suggestion - the Norse couldn't get their tongues around the Pictish language place names. Have you seen the PC name for the Western Isles now? Its in Gaelic (well Erse actually) Totally beyond me so I'll stick to the"Western Isles"