Priddy Circles forum 6 room
Image by postman
close
more_vert

Evergreen Dazed wrote:
juamei wrote:
The question is whether he paying _enough_ though... I'm sure he didn't mean for all of this to happen, but I'm equally sure he wanted his field flattened...
Whether or not hes 'paying enough' is really a vexed issue and one which its probably best not to make a judgement on unless you are in possession of all of the facts.

You are sure he wanted the field flattened? What makes you say that?
Thats a pretty bold statement.

I get a little edgy about this kind of thing. The mentality of it unnerves me. Judgements being made by people based upon an emotional response or an inadequate comparison, whilst understandable in one sense, are no replacement for an analysis of the situation within a court of law.

This man accepted responsibility, has gone through a legal process and has received his penalty. If somebody thinks it's 'not enough', fine, but they need to be basing any argument on facts, or if they are not available, at least a solid comparison with the facts they are aware of, as some sort of starting point.

I agree with this point of view ED .. looking at the whole picture and all the facts before jumping to conclusions. I don't know the full facts but always thought that it was an untrained/ill informed worker who did the damage rather than the land owner himself. I know nothing about the other 'news' story mentioned by Carl but after doing a quick google search found this similar, possibly the same, story only the fine was considerably more: (apologies for DM link)
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2238252/Wealthy-homeowner-fined-125-000-felling-neighbours-tree-blocked-sea-views-hot-tub.html

At work else I'd reply further, but tjj highlighted it perfectly.. Neither ED or TJJ know the full facts but have jumped to the assumption that he didn't do it with malice and that the penalty befits the crime. We are all working on the facts available as (I assume) none of us were in court.

Its simple to me, will he pay enough to have the henge restored? If no, then he isn't paying enough.