Robin Hood and Little John 2
Image by Kammer

The Christian propoganda bit is very true and must be weedled out of the rest. Luckily it is easy to spot.

We have to be thankful for the folklore, no matter how sketchy it is. Without the oral traditions of the Irish 'peasants' that were transcribed by the early monks here noone would have been able to say that Newgrange was the Bru na Dagda, nor would any of the monuments upon Tara have their names, as these were only re-assigned after careful translations of 7th century manuscripts by the great John O'Donovan in 1836.

It is also to be noted that many of the clerics that wrote down the old sagas and histories were (at first) very sympathetic to the 'old ways' and the initial writings were very different from later ones that suffered from the censors hand.

The Irish tales of the Fir-Bolg and Da Danaans, being a pre-celtic super race of demi-gods, does tally with the now agreed invasion/settlement cycle in Ireland.

There is a root behind all these tales. Yes, many of them are distorted by thousands of years of Chinese Whispers, but there are echoes in there of the orders of events or a superceded mythos/religion that is lost forever.

My problem with all this is: I know 70% of it is clap-trap, but which 70%?

Hi FourWinds,

If you know 70% of it is clap-trap, but don't know which 70% it is, how do you know 70% of it is clap-trap? ;-)

I'm going to go even further out on a limb and suggest that we feel the essence of it all in our hearts. And if the Ancients were trying to connect with a greater spiritual being, who's to say that whatever connection we make spiritually at these places is any less or any more valid than theirs? The ritual practices to connect might not be the same at these sites. But the heartbeat of the site has been passed down to us via folklore and similar methods, so as their descendents, we can still feel the essential thread of the cosmos, despite a gap of 6,000 years.

And isn't that comforting? Makes me feel good, anyway.

xx treaclechops