The Greywethers 4
Image by Jane

tiompan wrote:
FourWinds wrote:
tiompan wrote:
Post Ruggles many of the Thom and Burl astro alignments have been binned .
But then who's to say Ruggles is correct? Just because it's the currently accepted theory and approach doesn't mean it's the right one. I'm not saying he's wrong, by the way, just pointing out that the flavour of the month isn't necessarily correct. The ideas it replaced could still be valid even though they're not in vogue.
I agree regarding Ruggles , Schaefer could be seen as flavour of the month right now , but what we can say is that Thom got it wrong in many ways .
Can't say I really know Schaefer's stuff, but your last comment about Thom being 'wrong in many ways' holds a cautionary note - he probably got it right in some ways and it is wrong of so many people to dismiss everything he did just because a lump of it isn't all that good.

FourWinds wrote:
tiompan wrote:
FourWinds wrote:
tiompan wrote:
Post Ruggles many of the Thom and Burl astro alignments have been binned .
But then who's to say Ruggles is correct? Just because it's the currently accepted theory and approach doesn't mean it's the right one. I'm not saying he's wrong, by the way, just pointing out that the flavour of the month isn't necessarily correct. The ideas it replaced could still be valid even though they're not in vogue.
I agree regarding Ruggles , Schaefer could be seen as flavour of the month right now , but what we can say is that Thom got it wrong in many ways .
Can't say I really know Schaefer's stuff, but your last comment about Thom being 'wrong in many ways' holds a cautionary note - he probably got it right in some ways and it is wrong of so many people to dismiss everything he did just because a lump of it isn't all that good.
We shouldn't throw out the baby with the bathwater and what Thom did has had a very positive impact , just a pity about the mistakes and even as far as I'm concerned MYs too .