Bluestonehenge forum 2 room
Image by harestonesdown
Bluestonehenge

So anyway​…

close
more_vert

Glad that someone has opened a positive thread for this fantastic news.

I feel a little worried on how to contribute to this thread in fear of "taking anyone's glory" or upsetting anyone, do you think it appropriate etiquette to wait until after MPP has done his talk before I contribute the limited knowledge I have of my parts of the dig to this thread?

Regards

Lilydee. x

Don't worry about etiquette. There's no payment, mind ...

I guess what we're interested in is in the colour of the fragments of excavated bluestone and what evidence was found to link the blaustones site with Stonehenge.

lilydee05 wrote:
Glad that someone has opened a positive thread for this fantastic news.

I feel a little worried on how to contribute to this thread in fear of "taking anyone's glory" or upsetting anyone, do you think it appropriate etiquette to wait until after MPP has done his talk before I contribute the limited knowledge I have of my parts of the dig to this thread?

Regards

Lilydee. x

I for one would like to hear your take on this. If anyone doesn't, I'd say it is their problem! First hand knowledge of the site ought to be invaluable to anyone properly interested in the subject.

lilydee05 wrote:
Glad that someone has opened a positive thread for this fantastic news.

I feel a little worried on how to contribute to this thread in fear of "taking anyone's glory" or upsetting anyone, do you think it appropriate etiquette to wait until after MPP has done his talk before I contribute the limited knowledge I have of my parts of the dig to this thread?

Regards

Lilydee. x

You are quite right to be concerned, but if you ask that sort of question here you unsurprisingly will be encouraged to share information. Irrespective of whether intellectual property is involved or not, the field group leader would normally be the person for volunteers to approach about guidance re protocols and particularly about matters of trust. It is after all the group’s reputation that is at stake not just the volunteers'. The WANHS field group do issue reminders to volunteers about do’s and don’ts so I am a little surprised this has come up. Given what has happened in the case of this site and the media coverage I think discussion surrounding intellectual property is likely at the group’s general meeting in a fortnight. You would be better advised to wait and benefit from that discussion and if not wanting to wait to telephone the chair JG and ask for guidance.

lilydee05 wrote:
Glad that someone has opened a positive thread for this fantastic news.

I feel a little worried on how to contribute to this thread in fear of "taking anyone's glory" or upsetting anyone, do you think it appropriate etiquette to wait until after MPP has done his talk before I contribute the limited knowledge I have of my parts of the dig to this thread?

Regards

Lilydee. x

What you decide to do with your information Lilydee is, of course, up to you. Personally, I've never been very happy when people say, "Look this is just between you and me." or, "Look, I'm telling you this in the strictest confidence." as it places a gagging order on those 'under the rose' and a block on its wider dissemination (when often a wider dissemination of information might, actually, be for the greater good). I'll go along with confidences of a personal nature but anything much outside that has the smell of 'information control' to me. This is Britain of the 21st century and not, even with all its present control freakery shortcomings, Communist China, North Korea or some patriarchal Arab state where control of the media is used to suppress or manipulate the flow of knowledge, information, free-speech and, in the end, the advancement of society as a whole.

So... I now tend to respond to any sub rosa whisper in my ear with a, "Sorry, I can't take onboard your restrictions so you can either tell me what you know (with the understanding that I'll make my own decisions whether or not to share that information with others) or you may prefer not to tell me at all." That tends to clear the air and allows for a more honest sharing of information between friends and groups. Personally, I believe the non-sharing of information is likely to foster mistrust, resentment and the eventual collapse of friendships, groups and even of societies. The situation is probably made even worse when something that was once known to one or two members of a group is then disclosed later to the whole group with a, "Sorry, but it was told to me in confidence." escape clause.

Sorry Goff, your thread is about discussing (openly and freely I hope) the Bluehenge discovery and so I'll say no more (at least not here :-) on the politics of that discovery. Hope MPP's talk goes well today Lilydee, and I'm sure I'm not alone in hoping you'll have something to say about it here.