I've mentioned his book What Happened In History on here before.. I first became aware of it in 1972 when it was the inspiration behind Roy Harper's The Lord's Prayer - the Youtube live in Sunderland version of which is a total tour de force, imo - and have had a copy of it for many years now. It is still available as a cheap paperback. Those that buy it will, I hope, agree that the old ones are sometimes the best. If anything I have read - I've not read the orange book - has inspired my interest in archaeology and the past..or present..it is this. A Bible, to me. Others may think differently and are free to do so.
close
T
One point that Lyotard arguably got right was a healthy " incredulity toward metanarratives." . That of course includes Bibles as well as lesser grand narratives .
Childe ,as I had mentioned here recently , was one of our greatest archaeologists , we have stood on his shoulders as well as a few others and that has helped in appreciating the problems posed by some of their over arching ideas .
There was also a recent Kenny Brophy comment pointing out the problems with Childe's theories , nevertheless the tacit nod towards to his abilities remained .
T
Confession: I knew nothing about Gordon Childe until seeing your post. I've just been reading a long article published by International Socialism which now seems essential reading (see link below). It seems he was also committed to the Labour Movement, Socialism and the fight against Fascism in the early 20th Century. Conversely, whatever he left as his legacy to prehistoric archaeology, to learn about the man is also to gain fresh insights into the political history of the 20th Century.
M
That made me think of the first book I came across on history, and it was H.G.Wells - Outline of History, the linear walking through history laid out chapter by chapter. How much of that book could be discredited today? But all knowledge is built upon previous writing and thought, so we are always in some way fumbling towards a truth....
"Wells was uncertain whether to place "the beginnings of settled communities living in towns" in Mesopotamia or Egypt. He was equally unsure whether to consider the development of civilisation something that arose from "the widely diffused Heliolithic Neolithic culture" or something that arose separately. But between the nomadic cultures that originated in the Neolithic Age and the settled civilisations to the south, he discerned that "for many thousands of years there has been an almost rhythmic recurrence of conquest of the civilizations by the nomads."
According to Wells, this dialectical antagonism reflected not only a struggle for power and resources, but a conflict of values. "Civilization, as this outline has shown, arose as a community of obedience, and was essentially a community of obedience. But . . . [t]here was a continual influx of masterful will from the forests, parklands, and steppes. The human spirit had at last rebelled altogether against the blind obedience of the common life; it was seeking . . . to achieve a new and better sort of civilization that should also be a community of will." Wells regarded the democratic movements of modernity as an aspect of this movement."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Outline_of_History
My two 'old' books are Glyn Daniels - The Megalithic Builders of Europe and Grahame Clark - Prehistoric England, and I still love Stuart's Piggotts - The Druids. Flawed or not, initial excitement as history unfolds is something to be treasured ;)
© 2026 Head Heritage.
Unless otherwise stated, the copyright in each work is the property of the respective contributor. For usage or questions, contact [email protected].