I was aware of that site but hadn't visited in a long while. It's really nicely done, will use it more often now. Cheers for the link.

Yep, I have always loved TMA but doesn't feel like a community anymore does it? The village pump forum bit does, but not TMA. It used to be fantastic, it felt like the central point for lots of people coming to the subject from many different areas. There was always something of interest.
Now it's one or two people completing their sticker albums and the conversation has dried up.
Add to that the lack of development, as you say, and it feels rather empty. Would be lovely to see some new features and more ideas.

MegP, by comparison, feels alive and when you visit, despite the layout chaos, it feels like people care about it.

Rhubarb crumble and cream AND custard? Oh blimey, yes.

This place was ruined by a certain troll being allowed to roam free for way too long.

I've no idea of the TMA structure or who 'Eds' are (do they reside on some middle England equivalent of Mt Olympus?), but would hope there'd be folk here trusted enough now willing to make positive site input if allowed...reckon less work to do here than needed on MegP. Still the site to beat for me, but perfection doesn't exist and can slip further away with the passage of time. My own hope is that there'd one day be a pocketable paper offshoot using TMA contributions over the last sixteen years that would be durable enough to take whatever the elements throw at it out in the field/wilderness. The recent 'site down' was, or should be taken as a warning that nothing in the 'e-world' really lasts. TMA and all folks endeavours one day w i l l go 'pfftt'. End of. Not necessarily of JC's choosing. Wiki 'Carrington Event'. Paper still rules for me, and, imo, should be this places legacy. Watch your figure (given up on mine)

I'd disagree re only a couple. By my reckoning there are still a good 50 posters who contribute at least 10 times a year to tma. And probably 20 or so who contribute a lot more than that. The comments on posts outnumber forum posts most days.

Not tried out the mp app but the screenshots look really good and I know they've put an awful lot of work in. Shame the main site is hard to navigate imo. I prefer tmas field notes, news etc too.

Like others I have concerns re the longevity of tma, the silence of the eds etc worries me slightly. However I'm aware they are for the most part long term contributors, a couple having let slip by accident over the years. I guess still seeing them without the mask and capes posting / commenting as normal means this place isn't adrift, just on autopilot.

Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Yep, I have always loved TMA but doesn't feel like a community anymore does it? The village pump forum bit does, but not TMA. It used to be fantastic, it felt like the central point for lots of people coming to the subject from many different areas. There was always something of interest.
Now it's one or two people completing their sticker albums and the conversation has dried up.
That's a depressing post, frankly. It's a community site, so it needs contributors to actually contribute posts rather than moan on the sidelines about the lack of action going on.

I'd love to see more new people coming with fieldnotes and photos and actually there are a lot more than one or two people who regularly contribute, across Ireland, Scotland, Wales and England. Spencer is a recent example of an enthusiastic new contributor and that's great to see. Would love to see some of the earlier contributors back but many like Geoff have their own websites now so it's difficult to imagine them posting everything in both places. Others like Kammer, Jane and Moth have simply moved on in their lives, it happens.

To my mind the forum is neither here or there, it's the database that makes TMA essential. It's always my first port of call when planning a trip somewhere new. There's also a lot of love for TMA beyond the contributors, it's used as a resource by a lot more folk than actually post here.