Detectorists 2

close
more_vert

And ended on a perfect note.. Lovely subtle play of characters, summer scenery and a 'find' at the end. Hopefully we will have more.

T tjj

moss wrote:
And ended on a perfect note.. Lovely subtle play of characters, summer scenery and a 'find' at the end. Hopefully we will have more.
For once Moss, I'm afraid I have to disagree with you. It compounded all the reservations expressed earlier in this thread and it was dishonest in its 'harmlessness'. The 'find' was so obviously a replica of the very precious Alfred Jewel which was found in 1693 - implying there may be another one out there buried by an ancient site was at the very least disingenuous. Especially following as it did in schedules on from The Last Kingdom on BBC2 - which was very good albeit Winchester getting mixed up with Chippenham.

moss wrote:
And ended on a perfect note.. Lovely subtle play of characters, summer scenery and a 'find' at the end. Hopefully we will have more.
I loved it like I have all the way though. The first series introduced us to all the characters as such and how it was likely to pan out. This second series has dealt more with their personal problems, again exactly as intended with an indicator of things coming right for them all at the end of it.

The next series (I hope there is one anyway) should reach its conclusion...but will it end with them finding the 'big one'? I doubt it personally as I don't think it would fit in with the overall theme which has been acted out brilliantly. But I'm sure it will conclude in a way that will leave everyone happy, unless they are taking it far more seriously than is necessary that is.

There is of course a Christmas special to come for us to look forward to and I'm wondering if we could maybe see a TV film coming out in time?

I must confess to have watched with increased ambivalence. My personal view about metal detectors, as opposed to some who wield them, is that they should be an essential bit of kit when conducting a professional or supervised archaeological investigation. Yes, the two series throughout have centred on a club, where all finds are displayed at meetings, archaeological merit being not a factor. That this s h o u l d be the way to go for any puchaser and user has been implicit. However, I would have preferred that the programme gone further, by the additional showing at the end of each episode an advisory regarding club membership, perhaps the address of the national body, should one exist - I know not - finds reporting and trespass. There will inevitably be, among those fresh purchasers or who will recieve gifts this Christmas as a consequence of viewing, some who will ignore even this, let alone the series' implicit message. I have not forgotten in years gone by seeing figures in the gloaming on the Chiltern gap near Princes Risborough and doubting their intent, and having now found a site which, from study of aerial imagery seems to be of some size, and which, following advice from a senior archaeolgical figure I contacted, I will be alerting RCAHMS to, I am personally increasingly concerned by the activities of the unscrupulous. As for the series on an overall 'production' level, I think I preferred the sparser feel of series one. Throwing money at something does not always improve it. Yes, still enjoyed, but primarily for watching the performances of the central characters. That popularity seems to have merited a Christmas special, hmmm. I really hope that that and any future series at least has an advisory as per above. It must also be remembered that this series, contrary to my original view, may well be sold to and seen overseas, where the users of detectors may have even freer rein and fewer clubs. Sorry to be a perhaps unexpected killjoy, but this is now my measured view of Detectorists, and I'm sticking to it. I will continue to watch should there be more, but always with a degree of unease.