Kilmartin book

Prompted by Howburn Digger's response to my preceding topic post (ta), I've been delving on the net about Kilmartin, wondering if the reason for so very many sites in the area was that it was perhaps a place of healing, and whether this was reflected in the area's botany today. In the course of this I've found what looks a very interesting book: An Animate Landscape: Rock Art and the Prehistory of Kilmartin, Argyll, Scotland, by Jones, Jones, Freedman etc. This was on the Oxbow Books website on special offer at £12-95, instead of the usual £38. Subsequent checking on Amazon found it at £35 there..though there were some good links to other publications there, inc some very good cheap handbooks by Birlinn Books, a fine publishing house imo. Anyway, here's the Oxbow link: http://www.oxbowbooks.com/oxbow/an-animate-landscape.html ..they have some other offers that may be of interest too. I've only been to Kilmartin once, like Howburn, on honeymoon - after a week on the Clyde Puffer VIC 32..google, totally recommended - and my appetite to return has been whetted.

spencer wrote:
Prompted by Howburn Digger's response to my preceding topic post (ta), I've been delving on the net about Kilmartin, wondering if the reason for so very many sites in the area was that it was perhaps a place of healing, and whether this was reflected in the area's botany today. In the course of this I've found what looks a very interesting book: An Animate Landscape: Rock Art and the Prehistory of Kilmartin, Argyll, Scotland, by Jones, Jones, Freedman etc. This was on the Oxbow Books website on special offer at £12-95, instead of the usual £38. Subsequent checking on Amazon found it at £35 there..though there were some good links to other publications there, inc some very good cheap handbooks by Birlinn Books, a fine publishing house imo. Anyway, here's the Oxbow link: http://www.oxbowbooks.com/oxbow/an-animate-landscape.html ..they have some other offers that may be of interest too. I've only been to Kilmartin once, like Howburn, on honeymoon - after a week on the Clyde Puffer VIC 32..google, totally recommended - and my appetite to return has been whetted.
Much of the book centres on excavations around two rock art sites . Torbhlaran and Ormaig .
http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/site/372/torbhlaren.html

Chapter 5 covers the palynology of the Dun valley and includes mentions of trees ,shrubs and climbers ,heaths , herbs (47) ,Spore prodcuing plants and aquatic plants .

spencer wrote:
Prompted by Howburn Digger's response to my preceding topic post (ta), I've been delving on the net about Kilmartin...

I've only been to Kilmartin once, like Howburn, on honeymoon - after a week on the Clyde Puffer VIC 32..google, totally recommended - and my appetite to return has been whetted.

I've been to Kilmartin many times. The first time I went with my OH it was our first holiday together but it was certainly no honeymoon (though it was a ten day picnic).

http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/forum/?thread=72560&message=915145

I had been to Kilmartin a couple of times before the visit I mentioned in the above post. They were shorter stops on the way back from fishing in Loch Awe (certainly not with my OH). I have been many times since.

This is the only puffer you should travel on.

http://youtu.be/B_0WokmBEFM

Lost forever on their Highland Voyage.

http://youtu.be/G7ego75oFKM

Book your seats... tickets are going fast...

http://youtu.be/auU6Zdkun_I

"From Ardrishaig to Crinan, the best trip I've bin in, the Crinan Canal for me..."

As an aside, I am heading up to Scotland again this summer and have just booked a nights B+B in Kilmartin - can't wait!

spencer wrote:
I've been delving on the net about Kilmartin, wondering if the reason for so very many sites in the area was that it was perhaps a place of healing, and whether this was reflected in the area's botany today.
Compared with the more well known putataive "place of healing " , it's a huge area (usually considered to encompass Achnabreck to Carnassarie , at least ,and the coast inland to Glasvaaar .) . Contemporary palynology wouldn't tell us much about what was available in the past . Networks were clearly in place with Ireland , the rest of Scotland and there is evidence for continental associations in the area too . Any healing plants could have been traded rather than having those requiring healing to travel to the area of origin and there is no evidence to suggest that there were any particular abnormalities among the remains found in the area or any plants that were not be found in similar ecologies elsewhere .
Most importantly , how would we recognise a place of healing in the absence of written records ?

Whenever I visit an area for a few days to explore the sites, I attempt to obtain a local gazetteer or written guide to what is there on the ground.

Probably the best such publication that I possess is the Kilmartin book published by the RCAHMS:

http://www.oxbowbooks.com/oxbow/kilmartin.html

I can not praise this book highly enough. If you get this one, then you can give away all of the other books you have about what survives around Kilmartin, because it's all in here (apart from any recent findings, of course).

Don't be put off by the academic sounding title. It's not boring, it has maps, drawings, diagrams and descriptions of everything.

This book has enabled me to visit sites which I would not have considered and some don't appear on TMA, yet.

I wish I could obtain such a wonderful book for all of the other places I visit.