Ritual

close
more_vert

> >To me life in Western Europe is full of ritual activity and pretty devoid of spirituality. Can this be applied to the past? probably not, I think ethnological studies of none western (capitalist) societies are possibly our best chance at trying to understand Britain 5000 years ago.

>I totally agree with this. There's certainly caveats about it not being simple, but they're kind of obvious. To me the main point is that when we're looking at prehistory, there are huge, inevitable, unresolvable gaps in our image of life then. Some people cut loose and fill the gaps with wishful thinking, some hold tight and refuse to commit to anything that can't be scientifically verified. (Of course most people sit somewhere between these poles on the continuum somewhere...)

A pretty good example of an attempt to scientifically apply ethnology to archaeology is David Lewis-Williams' "The Mind in the Cave: Consciousness and the Origins of Art."

> A pretty good example of an attempt to scientifically apply ethnology to archaeology is David Lewis-Williams' "The Mind in the Cave: Consciousness and the Origins of Art."

Definitely one of the best places to start. He's a little too staunchly rationalist for my taste, and I've never thought that staunch rationalists were the best people to really get under the skin of folk who crawled into mountains to paint animals ;-) However, within the confines of the academy, Lewis-Williams does a great job of being open-minded.

I loved his intro, where he depicts a sequence of human encounters with these painted caves, each from a different epoch, to illustrate the evolution of our relationship to them. It's the thing that brought home to me most vividly what a complete and utter traumatic shock the implications of Darwinian evolution must have been for the 19th century. Specifically, the true depth of our past, in contrast the that quaint Bishop Ussher-stylee Christian view of it stretching back all of 6000 or so years.

His earlier book, right at the roots of the recent wave of "ethnoarchaeology", 'Believing and seeing', is probably out of date in some respects now, but is a beautiful piece of writing, well worth getting hold of if you can.