Hi Fitz -
Yeah...get what your saying. I'm not into getting rid of people. We all make mistakes - but it'd better if he could at least give other references when questioned, besides "I say so" or "gerrup and have a look for y'selves." (Having a look at the other sites he's posted there's no reference to anything apart from his own words). I know it's not always possible to verify it - especially when it comes to a truly new discovery. But I think in this site particularly (and the Toggly Woggly non-cup&ring stone) we have an example of a site that isn't a 'possible,' but more of an 'incredibly improbable.' There's unanimity on it across this site apart from with Mr ShirtLifter himself. I just the TMA eds (who I assume are reading this thread) let commonsense prevail.