The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   Orkney Forum Start a topic | Search
Orkney
Re: Interesting writing
26 messages
Select a forum:
tiompan wrote:
In reply to Resonox's post , but I can't access to quote from ,so apologies .

The markings are much closer to the earlier style found in the Neolithic -Bronze age in Orkney than the much later Ogham . These markings are to be found on the "side" of slabs e.g. Brodgar Farm and lintels . We don't know the audience , if any , they were intended for . The markings could be apotropaic , intended as a communication between the engraver and stone or spirits .No need for the most obvious surface to be used , it is often the case in rock art that what appears to be a perfect surface to moderns is avoided in favour of something that to us appears much less useful . In this case , maybe the intended audience was a relatively contemporary one .

It is so difficult to give an accurate guess(an oxymoron?)...not knowing the size of the stone or the situation of it's discovery site...I only suggested it's similarity to the Ballymote examples of Ogham as a comparison...not as an answer. The wearing/erosion/moss isn't as severe as it might be if it were exposed....and the stone doesn't have the discolouration associated with being in the ground....I'd suggest a real expert gets the chance to examine it minutely.
I still find it perplexing that archeos wanted it in exchange for a plaster-cast, without giving any clues as to what they thought it was(I wonder why they didn't take a cast for themselves?) were they invited to the house to look at it or was the stone taken to them?


Reply | with quote
Posted by Resonox
13th January 2011ce
13:30

In reply to:

Re: Interesting writing (tiompan)

Messages in this topic: