The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian

Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   General Discussion Forum Start a topic | Search
The Modern Antiquarian
Re: Ley Lines
158 messages
Select a forum:
The Sea Cat wrote:
Jane wrote:
The Sea Cat wrote:
megadread wrote:
Jane wrote:
Sanctuary wrote:

So what has happened since, is the ley-line idea still fashionable or simply seen as a hit and miss or chance thing? .


Yep. It's unproven mumbo jumbo. There are so many things in the landscape that if you look for patterns for long enough you'll always find things that line up. Just cos they do doesn't mean anything.


Wot she said.


No. I don't agree at all, but then it's all down to the experience/experiencer. That way possibilities lie.

:-)


Au contraire. Experience proves nothing. Only repeatable scientific experiments prove things.

:-) back atcha!


That's utter nonsense. Personal sentient experience is completely valid.

There may be that which is scientifically unmeasurable and unprovable. Such a thing doesn't require god, since it's perfectly feasible that the universe isn't laid out in its entirety in a form that we can observe and label. Therefore personal experience would become more significant that science in these areas - theoretically speaking.

On the other hand, once you start to give weight to "personal sentient experience" when attempting to arrive at objective truths, you hit the problem that "personal sentient experience" is different for every human being, and our minds are capable of quite gargantuan feats of... well, self-delusion.

Many Christians, for example, are convinced that they've been visited by the Virgin Mary, or that they've spoken to Jesus. I don't believe that they're lying or mentally ill, and I don't believe in God. So that would tend to suggest that objective, real experiences are filtered through the lens of personal belief in such a way that allows the mind to frame them in a personally meaningful fashion. Put simply, "personal sentient experience" is real but subjective, and it can't be relied upon when attempting to extrapolate objective truths. In my personal, sentient opinion, of course. ;)


Reply | with quote
Posted by Mustard
11th November 2010ce
08:59

In reply to:

Re: Ley Lines (The Sea Cat)

1 reply:

Re: Ley Lines (The Sea Cat)

Messages in this topic: