The Modern Antiquarian. Stone Circles, Ancient Sites, Neolithic Monuments, Ancient Monuments, Prehistoric Sites, Megalithic MysteriesThe Modern Antiquarian
Home Latest Posts Forums Maps Help
Browse Sites News Blog Contributors The Books
Head To Head   The Modern Antiquarian   General Discussion Forum Start a topic | Search
The Modern Antiquarian
Re: Time Team R.I.P. ?
145 messages
Select a forum:
tiompan wrote:
The astro bit was done in a hurry and a possibility became a certainty in a few minutes .


Yeah. Some things have a habit of doing that on TV.

tiompan wrote:
Standing stones to notches are dodgy at the best of times but this one didn't "work" anyway .


Not sure the dodgy tag can be applied with a broad brush. Everything is suspect until proven/observed anyway, but once observed it is fact whether intentional or otherwise. Until then they have to be taken as iffy (even if likely from preliminary observation). The intentionality of many alignments will never be established without the presence of a second marker. For me a notch can be a second marker, though. You have three points in a line: the stone, the notch and the sun. When these happen on 'random' dates it can cause a problem, but then you have to look at instances such as Labbamologa church in Cork. Here the original church does not face due east, but points to the sun rise on the Saint's Day. A stone/notch/sun rise alignment could just mark someone's birthday.

I assume someone checked this one out to know that it doesn't work? I'm only repeating my question because you have stated categorically that it's wrong. We both agree that Time Team jumped the gun in declaring it to be so. As you're being so definite I assume you're stating from observed fact.


Reply | with quote
FourWinds
Posted by FourWinds
10th January 2010ce
14:26

In reply to:

Re: Time Team R.I.P. ? (tiompan)

2 replies:

Re: Time Team R.I.P. ? (tiompan)
Re: Time Team R.I.P. ? (tiompan)

Messages in this topic:

Terms & Conditions  |  Home  |  Julian Cope presents Head Heritage Top of page