Forums | Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic

The Modern Antiquarian

Home	Latest Posts	Forums	Maps	Help

Browse Sites	News	Blog	Contributors	The Books

Head To Head

The Modern Antiquarian

Callanish Forum

Start a topic | Search

Callanish

Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic

59 messages

Select a forum:

whatisthat wrote:

I think TMA should focus on monuments and their history which I suppose means academic and aesthetic. The mystical stuff seems to be focused on self and (modern) personal beliefs. IMO the two sides are incompatible.

I disagree. They're incompatible at their extremes, but there are areas in the middle where the two can meet. For example, the belief that megaliths are sited according to some form of "earth energy" does not have to be incompatible with archaeology... unless you wander into the territory of druids floating blue stones around on anti-gravity energy cushions or such like :D

I have no view on the subject, to be honest. I have no idea whether there's mysterious energy pulsing through the land, or whether we live in a cold, mechanistic universe. I've pretty much given up trying to work it out and simply enjoy the landscape of my country for what it is and how it feels. I just don't like the utterly dismissive tone that's sometimes adopted towards anyone who doesn't hold a strictly mystical-free view of all things megalithic. I mean why, FFS, shouldn't we take alternative views seriously, so long as they're not utterly outlandish and at odds with known history and physics? I don't see why everyone should be tarred with the same brush as the-poster-whose-name-shall-not-be-mentioned.

This topic is locked

Posted by doktoratomik
6th September 2006ce
18:13

(Kammer, Sep 06, 2006, 12:47)

Re: You are joking sire? (CianMcLiam, Sep 06, 2006, 13:01)
Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 13:06)
- Re: You are joking sire? (Rhiannon, Sep 06, 2006, 13:30)
  - Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 13:37)
    - Re: You are joking sire? (Rhiannon, Sep 06, 2006, 13:53)
      - Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 14:05)
        Re: You are joking sire? (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 14:26)
        Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 14:36)
        Re: You are joking sire? (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 14:59)
        Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 15:02)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Kammer, Sep 06, 2006, 14:33)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Rhiannon, Sep 06, 2006, 14:43)
        Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 14:45)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Rhiannon, Sep 06, 2006, 14:47)
        Re: You are joking sire? (jacksprat, Sep 06, 2006, 15:37)
        Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 15:40)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Rockrich, Sep 06, 2006, 15:53)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Rhiannon, Sep 06, 2006, 15:54)
        Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 15:56)
        Re: You are joking sire? (Spaceship mark, Sep 06, 2006, 16:06)
        Re: You are joking sire? (CianMcLiam, Sep 06, 2006, 16:21)
        Re: You are joking sire? (jacksprat, Sep 06, 2006, 16:25)
        Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 18:01)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 18:13)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 18:16)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 18:30)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 18:38)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (CianMcLiam, Sep 06, 2006, 18:33)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Moth, Sep 06, 2006, 23:53)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 18:27)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 18:38)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (nigelswift, Sep 06, 2006, 18:50)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 19:13)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 19:28)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 19:35)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 19:42)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 20:02)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 20:10)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Hob, Sep 06, 2006, 20:32)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Paulus, Sep 06, 2006, 20:47)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 20:54)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (nigelswift, Sep 07, 2006, 07:00)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 06, 2006, 20:51)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Littlestone, Sep 06, 2006, 21:38)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Hob, Sep 06, 2006, 21:51)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (Littlestone, Sep 06, 2006, 21:59)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 22:22)
        Re: Mystical, Academic or Aesthetic (FourWinds, Sep 07, 2006, 07:33)
- Re: You are joking sire? (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 13:31)
  - Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 13:35)
    - Re: You are joking sire? (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 13:51)
      - Re: You are joking sire? (whatisthat, Sep 06, 2006, 18:12)
        Re: You are joking sire? (nigelswift, Sep 07, 2006, 07:58)
- Re: You are joking sire? (Kammer, Sep 06, 2006, 13:39)
  - Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 13:55)
    - Re: You are joking sire? (Kammer, Sep 06, 2006, 14:14)
      - Re: You are joking sire? (doktoratomik, Sep 06, 2006, 14:27)
Time out! (Kammer, Sep 07, 2006, 08:39)

Terms & Conditions | Home | Julian Cope presents Head Heritage

Top of page

The Modern Antiquarian

In reply to:

2 replies:

Messages in this topic: