Presumed consent.

close
more_vert

Personally I think it's a great idea.

What needs to be borne in mind is that (a) a person can opt-out by signing up to a register; and (b) the next of kin can block organ donation if they have a problem with it.

So there's no real chance of having your organs harvested should it be a problem with either yourself or your loved-ones. Countries which have adopted this policy have -- overnight -- ended the shortage for most organs and slashed waiting lists.

If there is a problem, it's going to be the financial cost. Transplant surgery and rehab is extremely expensive. If the NHS finds itself performing (let's say) twice as many transplants per annum then it'll have to either get additional funding from the government (unlikely) or else divert funds from elsewhere within the NHS (more likely).

grufty jim wrote:
Personally I think it's a great idea.

What needs to be borne in mind is that (a) a person can opt-out by signing up to a register; and (b) the next of kin can block organ donation if they have a problem with it.

Well part (a) seems fine and reasonable, but I thought that this was designed to alleivate the problems that could arise re (b).

I mean, I would imagine that it's difficult alot of the time to expect someone grieving for a loved one to make such a decision. I imagine that's why most organs 'go to waste' basically.

I was under the impression that in part this was such a good idea because it removes that burden also.

As I said, the implications re children and those not of 'sound mind' are quite vast, but maybe where we can we have to be encouraged to be hard and fast about it.

EDIT: http://www.bma.org.uk/ap.nsf/Content/OrganDonationPresumedConsent


There is something positive here in that although relatives can object, it does seem more likely, according to this report anyway, that knowledge their loved one(s) 'gave consent' (as this would amount to) would suffice and too remove for them the burden of having to go into any decision making. Makes sense I suppose.
I wouldn't like to think however my wishes could be overrode either.
Moot point maybe.
Where children are concerned, it does seem much more difficult.

x