Arbor Low forum 11 room
Image by thesweetcheat
Arbor Low

What Is It??

close
more_vert

Perhaps the UK henges were trading centres at some point in their life, but in Ireland (the only other places they exist I believe) I don't think it fits the bill.

Take Forenaghts Great where I was yesterday:
http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/site/6219

Excavations here found a network of ritual pits and a couple of cists, one of these at the base of the longstone itself. There are 4 other (very) longstones in the area, none of them in henges and at least two mark burials.

The east and west entrances to henges do not fit a trading post theory for me. These mark the equinox and thus are ritual. A trading post would probably have four entrances at the cardinal points, showing through great symbolism that 'all were welcome' no matter where they came from.

The henge at Dowth is in the midst of a passage tomb cemetery. The one below Newgrange similarly. The Giant's Ring near Belfast encloses a passage tomb.

Avebury is a henge. Does that look like a trading post to you?

I hate to use the 'R' word too much, but henges must have had a large ritual context. Admittedly, that ritual <i>could</i> have been to do with trading, but I personally don't see it being so.

I have spent a good dela of time pondering the what and why of megalithic structures. To some extent I think they were a statement of what could be achieved. Whenever man harnesses a technology, he pushes it to the limits. Pyramids, henges, cathedrals, bridges, and skyscrapers are all examples of people showing how far they can go with their particular technology.

Stone was the raw material of the megalith builders. To begin with it furnished them with tools that enabled them to achieve mastery over their hostile world with knives, axes, and arrow heads. As they discovered methods to manipulated bigger and bigger stones, they were symbolically achieving dominance over the very earth itself and they wanted to express that in a powerful way. Building a massive stone circle is just such a statement. It says "Look how powerful we are".

I imagine that these statements of achievement would be tightly incorporated into their religious beliefs, so I tend to agree with Fourwinds that the sites would have had a predominantly ritual function.

In some ways it's not too different from modern religions where people glorify their god with human achievement while at the same time investing their god with their own specific aspirations. Religion is just another tool to manipulate the world. "The will of God" is nothing of the sort. It's the will of some person or group. I think Neolithic people may have had an attitude something like:

"We can manipulate the stones. We can make them stand up when by themselves they fall over. See how we command the earth spirits to rise up and do our bidding. We are the chosen ones. The true believers."

Avebury does look very much like a trading post to me - it has four entrances corresponding to the four cardinal points, a good supply of fresh water and is located close to the Ridgeway - 'Europe's Oldest Road'. That's not to say that trading was all that Avebury was used for - something that spectacular would surely have also been used for ceremonial purposes.

And the ditch? Pigpens of course.

It might be a good idea to question what we are calling trade. Axes for example may not have been anything like the trade goods that we commonly think of, it may be that the procurement of the axe may have been an integral part a the quest that took people across the country in an effort to appease the gods. I wonder exactly how much design variance there is with axes of a particular type, that might give some confirmation that they were many produced by a few, or more individually created.