Hi Rune,
although it's a good excuse for a trip to Cumbria you can save yourself a bit of time by nipping down to your local hardware shop and buying a bag of plaster of paris - calcined gypsum.
If you wanted a bit of the 'hard stuff ' you could always trawl your local junk shop for a nice alabaster ornament and then apply a hammer to it to obtain some decent chunks of the stuff - saying that, some alabaster is calcite - a kick in the arse away from gypsum.