The Fylingdales Stone forum 1 room
Image by fitzcoraldo
close
more_vert

Well aren't you the lucky one living near it.....what about the rest of us?

Here's a couple of emails from Britarch -

"As the person responsible for the laser scanning of the stone it's exceptionally fragile due to the action of the fire on the moor.
If a single person were to attempt a rubbing of the stone, there's a good chance the carved surfaces would detach and be lost forever.

Alistair Carty
Technical Director
Archaeoptics Ltd.


> Alistair,
>
> Surely, a good art conservator should be able to stabilize the surface
enough
> for its safe transport to somewhere that it could reside under glass? Even
if
> the state of technology is not advanced enought to tell us more about it
now,
> it should be preserved for the future when that situation might change.
>
> It seems that burying it again it such a fragile state will condemn the
> surface to fragmentation through water action and changes in ground
> temperature.
>
> Do you know if a larger image will be made public?
>
> Cheers,
>
> John


Surely if this article is so fragile then redepositing it to the soil will
in itself be destructive before the soil water and animal actions take a hold. Is this political correctness gone completely insane? BA artefacts
are rare enough and the fact that this as come to light all be it out of
context etc that we should use this to further our knowledge of this little
understood period in our history.

Rob "

Oh and the comment about pillboxes was meant to highlight Redfern's (potential) lack of knowledge of prehistory. But you've seen it haven't you?

Sure we could dig up every single panel of rock art and put them in museums but rock art is not just about the carvings themselves, it is also about the landscape and the setting - context.
Surely archaeology has moved away from artifact obsession
Would you sanction the excavation and removal of a standing stone to be exhibited in a museum? Long Meg has some lovely carving, why not rip her out of the ground, I'm sure all those thousands of hands that touch her spirals every year can't be doing her any good?
There are over 10,000 burial monuments on the North York Moors, most have been dug and most of the artifacts now languishing in non-North Yorkshire museums, many unlabelled with their context lost.
I take it you'd be happy to travel to Whitby or Scarbrough museum to visit this stone or would you prefer to have it somewhere closer to where you live? Why don't you come up here and check out the beautiful stones they already have in their collections, better still get yourself out onto the moors and see rock art in situ, I'll happily be your guide and I guarantee you will not be disappointed.
Why do you need to have the actual rock in a museum, what is wrong with an accurate copy?
This stone has survived 3 or 4 millennia in the lovely moorland peat and this is not the first fire to effect the moor.

They've done it before
http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/site/2426