Lewis and Harris 14
Image by drewbhoy
Lewis and Harris

Sleeping Beauty

"The comparison between Thornborough gravel and Lewis wind power doesn't stand up. They're nothing like each other."

I guess it depends on the angle we look at them from. Society wants or needs to use much of the land in this country but there should be agreed exempted areas where other priorities can be chosen - birds, ancient sites or whatever. Thornborough and Callanish have very strong claims for inclusion in those under the "ancient sites" classification.

As things stand the "view" at Callanish isn't something that falls within the protection system. HA has argued that under the new protection system there should be provision for inclusion of "setting" and, exceptionally, viewscape as part of the area that could be scheduled.

Having read the links about this site there seem to be many reasons why this application should be denied. Not just the safety of the birds but also the land itself. There seems to be evidence of peat being affected by building turbines.
Whilst I am in favour of alternative energy solutions, I do think these should be found in a responsible way bearing in mind the wishes of the local people as well as the importance of preserving landscapes such as this.
There are rules governing the siting of wind farms and if these are followed this application must be denied. However, once again, this application involves business and the god money with the usual promises of jobs for the locals etc which never seem to come about

Sorry to go on about it but it makes me so cross that business seems to think it should be the first consideration when there are guidelines showing that what they want should not even be considered

Elaine

I would agree with your sentiments in the case of a TV aerial or radio mast or a quarry, but when it comes to clean power I throw out all considerations. The planet and the environment come first. Plain and simple.

If the evidence of damage to the peat (itself only 3000 years old and a recent invader to these parts) was being damaged by turbines was strong enough then I would be against them, because the environmental damage caused <i>might</i> just outway the good they will do.