The Nine Stones of Winterbourne Abbas forum 8 room
Image by Moth
The Nine Stones of Winterbourne Abbas

Stone Not Circle

close
more_vert

Sanctuary wrote:
A lot of the oldest circles (well those where I live anyway alongside Bodmin Moor), seemed to have been marked out like more of a demarcation exercise rather than a perfect circle. Liken it to kids marking out an area to play footy in.
Absolutely - that is what I meant - the enclosure was more important than the circumference. In fact, mightn't the circumference not really have been important at all- perhaps even to be avoided? Given their skill, it would have been so easy, even simpler, to make.

And that is an interesting thought that the later true circles were an idealisation!

That is very much often the case with the development os sacred architecture elsewhere

nix wrote:
Sanctuary wrote:
A lot of the oldest circles (well those where I live anyway alongside Bodmin Moor), seemed to have been marked out like more of a demarcation exercise rather than a perfect circle. Liken it to kids marking out an area to play footy in.
Absolutely - that is what I meant - the enclosure was more important than the circumference. In fact, mightn't the circumference not really have been important at all- perhaps even to be avoided? Given their skill, it would have been so easy, even simpler, to make.

And that is an interesting thought that the later true circles were an idealisation!

That is very much often the case with the development os sacred architecture elsewhere

Circularity, or an approximation of , was clearly important for a group of monuments i.e. causewayed enclosures , henges ,passage graves , stone circles ,ring cairns ,kerb cairns in contrast to the linear cursus , Long barrows ,linear cemeteries etc . If enclosure was all that mattered we might expect more rectangularity .
Some of the earlier examples were not only bigger but were also more circular than later examples e.g. Brodgar ,Stonehenge ,Llandegai , Flagstones etc. There are exceptions like Castlerigg and Long Meg but generally the smaller and usually later circles ,despite being easier to mark out were if anything less circular .