Stonehenge 181
Image by Moth
Stonehenge

Stone shifting 5

I think it helps our credibility. It shows that we've done our homework.

If we just went ahead and used nylon rope, there would be those who would dismiss the entire project as bogus. They may be completely unqualified to make such a judgement (e.g. reporters), but they'll make it anyway.

If part of our presentation is that we've carried out experimentation using replica neolithic rope and have concluded that it would work just as well as modern rope for the project, then we have provided a reasonable justification for our choice of using modern rope.

Yes, test and display. And the same goes for anything else - does anyone have an axe or antler pick or bone shovel or replicas? We could dig a small hole on the day. And I'm sure the more artistic of us could put together a display, and maybe some paintings (no names!) of the original people using exactly our method. (Actually, all of those ideas would look OK on the website in advance).

Based on what has been said, here's my draft reply to her. Is this in line with what we all think?

_____________


Dear Anja,

Thankyou so much for giving us such a detailed and helpful reply. I have now shared it with the rest of the group.

We share your uncertainty about whether ropes were used, but are hoping to demonstrate several possibilities and perhaps gain some understanding about which method works best. We have made some engineering calculations and believe a force of 7 tons would be required for one of these methods (perhaps more to allow for error), and would assume we could use several ropes together for this. We would be interested to know if you are aware of the amount such ropes might tend to stretch.

Our feeling at present is that it is unlikely that we would obtain permission to use anything other than modern ropes for the hauling-up process, although we will make full enquiries about that once we have more details. Also, at present, we are unable to consider purchase of large quantities from yourselves because of finance. We are a group of people who have come together with an intention, and as yet we have no sponsors or grants. Nevertheless, we have hopes that this will change shortly. We are developing a website at http://stonehengineers.co.uk/ which should be available early next month (at present you can view some of our experimental logos!) and once this is completed we shall be able to explore the possibilities for sponsorship and broadcasting. Please visit the site when it is complete as it will be designed to show exactly what we propose to do. We intend to run a series of experiments on the means of transporting and erecting various sized stones, culminating with the erection of the trilithon just in time to greet the Sostice sunrise next year.

We do feel, as a minimum, we should like to purchase a small quantity of rope, Linden Bast and perhaps Hide for both testing and demonstration purposes. Even if we are forced to use modern ropes we should be very grateful for your help and would be very happy to give publicity to Hardanger Fartøyvernsenter. Perhaps you could come over in June and help us pull the ropes!

Best wishes from
The Stonehengeneers Team
Please reply to: [email protected]