Raich forum 1 room
Image by thesweetcheat
close

It's been brought to my attention that a small wind farm development (two turbines) is planned for not far from the [[Raich]] stone circle.

There is a concern that the turbines will impact on the wider landscape associated with (and viewed from) the [[Raich]] stone circle, dominating the surrounding area. Although the actual site of the proposed turbines is in a field between North Balnoon farm and Balnoon Wood (map here) which is maybe a kilometre to the north-east of the circle, so the stones themselves are not under threat, rather their context in the landscape.

Having not visited this site I don't know what effect the turbines will have on the stones, but certainly from the OS map it looks like they will be visible from the circle.

I'm pro-renewable energy, but also pro-ancient sites. In this case it looks to me like the turbines will be far enough away to only create a visual impact, which is something that doesn't really bother me too much if I'm honest. But I thought I would draw it to the attention of others in case anyone feels more strongly.

If anyone wants to object (or read more about the proposed development) the planning application number is
APP/2011/1277 which can be viewed on the Aberdeenshire Council Planning website.

BigSweetie wrote:
It's been brought to my attention that a small wind farm development (two turbines) is planned for not far from the [[Raich]] stone circle.

There is a concern that the turbines will impact on the wider landscape associated with (and viewed from) the [[Raich]] stone circle, dominating the surrounding area. Although the actual site of the proposed turbines is in a field between North Balnoon farm and Balnoon Wood (map here) which is maybe a kilometre to the north-east of the circle, so the stones themselves are not under threat, rather their context in the landscape.

Having not visited this site I don't know what effect the turbines will have on the stones, but certainly from the OS map it looks like they will be visible from the circle.

I'm pro-renewable energy, but also pro-ancient sites. In this case it looks to me like the turbines will be far enough away to only create a visual impact, which is something that doesn't really bother me too much if I'm honest. But I thought I would draw it to the attention of others in case anyone feels more strongly.

If anyone wants to object (or read more about the proposed development) the planning application number is
APP/2011/1277 which can be viewed on the Aberdeenshire Council Planning website.

My doorstep, and I know most of the local people involved. It worked before so I'll try again. Cheers Andy, I'll speak to the people at Turriff Heritage, local councils district and community (I've emailed them already) and Aberdeen Archaeology as well.

edit Plenty room on the other side of Balnoon in any case and wouldn't interfere with Drachlaw and The Hare Stones. Plus out of sight from Yonder Bognie.

Visual impact matters, and can be grounds for EH to object -

http://heritageaction.wordpress.com/2011/05/21/english-heritage-objects-to-windfarm-in-archaeological-landscape-is-this-now-set-policy/

Might be worth asking them if (and how) this differs from previous cases.

The circle is up the hill opposite the Glendronach Distillery and I've emailed their office to see what they think about these turbines.

Letter of objection fired in.