Maeshowe 16
Image by JCHC

I hear what you're saying, but "... an inaccessible large island, vaguely located in the Outer Ocean due to the cold weather and choppy sea..." doesn't sound like Britain to me. Britain isn't vaguely located, it's only 30 miles off France - you can even see it on a clear day. to be vaguely located in the Outer Ocean surely means something further afield, whether that's Iceland, Greenland or even the coast of Norway, who knows?

as for "interesting" societies, I suppose that depends on what the Greeks would find interesting, but there were Inuits from the Alaskan Saqqaq culture settling in Greenland from 2000 BCE onwards. the settlement of Iceland took place much later, with Irish monks thought to be the first during the 8th century CE, prior to the arrival of Vikings expelled from Norway in the 9th century CE

Cheers
Andy

"...vaguely located in the Outer Ocean..."

Yep, it's all very vague. In English 'vaguely' can mean 'just about', as in vaguely remembered 'just remembered'. I think we might need to back to the original Greek to find out what they meant by 'vaguely' - it could mean an island 'just barely' glimpsed from France for example?

Much as I respect the Inuit's, I cant really see them as being the inspiration for an ancient Greek interest in a mythical island inhabited by a people they called the Hyperboreans; but who knows - it's all way beyond me. I've just got this gut feeling that knowledge of the megalithic structures of these islands, and the people that constructed them, travelled far further than we imagine or give credit for; but again, who knows...

The Greeks and the Inuits seems to be stretching things a bit too far. Britain would certainly have been remote to the Greeks - on the edge of the world of Ocean. Different perspective if you happen to be living in northern Europe - just across the channel you can see the cliffs of Dover - but not from the Med which was the limit of the civilised world.

I have always closely associated Hyperborea and the Hesperides. The rich source of tin, the Hesperides are surely Cornwall and Scilly (Greek - garden of the gods on the western extremity of the Greek world) and Hyperborea is surely most likely to be Britain or Ireland (any linguistic link between Hyperborea and Hibernia?) Hyperborea is "the blessed realm governed by Apollo, believed by the Greeks to be located beyond the north wind"- Yes that could mean Scandinavia, but Britain and Scandinavia are both north and west of Greece. - But what of Apollo the Sun God? There was a yearly tribute sent to Apollo's shrine at Delos from Hyperborea. I can't see the Scandinavians or the Eskimos sending walrus ivory or whale blubber all the way to Delos as tribute, can you?

Apollo's temple in Hyperborea as described by Hecateus sounds a lot like Stonehenge. Then there is the teaser about Apollo manifesting himself to his followers every 19 years- now what bell does a nineteen year cycle sound?

Thule could be Iceland or any of the northern or western isles off Scotland. Remote and glimpsed only rarely by mariners off course. Quite correct that first known colonists were Irish monks - the word "papa" occurs in a number of Icelandic place names. Ultima Thule = Greenland? Any evidence of any kind?