Beckhampton Avenue 4
Image by Chance
Beckhampton Avenue

Beckhampton Avenue

"I think you'd agree that there IS a need to get it fixed as soon as poss"

Yes, but not at ANY cost in terms of damage. To clarify (based on what they say, not my speculation):

"Doing nothing" is indeed the worst and most damaging option. Ergo, doing "something" (even tunnelling) is preferable, I agree.

However, it's not that simple. The "doing nothing" damage has been speculated to take a very long time to fully work itself out. They've suggested parameters of 300 or 1000 years, depending on the nature of the collapses, but they don't know which will apply. They've also suggested lower and upper limits to the amount of possible damage.

On the basis of their figures, you could speculate the comparison as follows:
Grouting tomorrow = 13 cubic metres of loss.
Tunnel tomorrow = 166 cubic metres of loss.
Do nowt for 1 year = between 2.5 and 4 cubic metres of natural loss.
(Though, natural loss may not be "smooth" over time - it could be a series of random collapses - they haven't said).

If you keep those figures firmly in mind, any press release that gives the impression that EH must go in there on white chargers and tunnel to prevent ongoing damage begins to look a little silly.

So I'd agree "there IS a need to get it fixed as soon as poss" but NOT necessarily by a means that imposes perhaps 66 years worth of natural damage on it!

But what do I know? I've probably got hold of the wrong end of the stick from their figures, and they don't say that at all. So ALL that's required is expert confirmation that I've got it entirely wrong.

- I knew what you meant Nigel, but wasn't sure others would - so at for the clarification.

I bet you heven't 'got hold of the wrong end'.

love

Moth

Guess your post just about sums it all up Nigel and I cant argue with it.

Just one thing to add re: your, "The "doing nothing" damage has been speculated to take a very long time to fully work itself out." Doing nothing allows technology (in this case conservation) to move on and provide different, perhaps better answers, to current problems. Balanced against that is my last image of Silbury a few weeks ago. No disrespect to Pete but I've looked at a lot of photos of Silbury over the last few days and the summit really does seem to be slumping; hope I'm wrong about that but if it is slumping then we really do have to do something pretty soon.