Pete, I'm having a few doubts about the grooves at WKLB being used for sharpening. When you showed us the Polisher I think that we were all surprised at the glass-like smothness of the surface. I remember our discussions as to whether a grinding paste must have been used, for example, try to get an edge on a chisel on a sheet of glass without any.
Comparing the marks at WKLB http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/post/20276 the surfaces are still rough, how is this possible?