Alton Priors forum 2 room
Image by notjamesbond
close
more_vert

Being a one time toxophilist myself I know a fair bit about what a bowman would give his right arm for :-) I've shot a yew bow and they're bloody hard to pull. The average non-compound bow (if you can find one these days) has a pulling strain of around 35-40 lbs. Yew long bows easily exceed 60lbs - some are up to 80 or 90 lbs. There aren't many folks around today that could even think of pulling one of those. One thing you would not have wanted to do was pick a fight with the right arm of a Welsh bowman!

Please don't make it personal and attack my every post (you've done it a few times now) - it ain't worth it, is it? Try reading the whole web page and take note of the 'too many knots in British yew trees' bit and that a tax was levied. The tax forcing all merchants to carry yew staves back into Britain is well documented - hey, they even mentioned it on Time Team the once, what more proof could you want? :-) I never said British bowmen were crap, just the British yews weren't that well suited to the job. We all know the bowmen were the best (but then we wrote history didn't we).

Irish yews are a sport of the bog standard yew - Taxus baccata. They are all descended from two trees found on a limestone crag in Fermanagh in the 1760s. They became popular in cultivation because they were straighter and resembled funereal cypresses and could be topiarised.

They certainly didn't exist during the longbow era, but possibly modern bowyers may prefer them to the ordinary yew. Whether "English yew was crap for making bows" or not is hardly a valid point - that WAS the yew wood that was used and with deadly affect by the largely Welsh archers.

Yews in the wild were cut and cropped for bows, those in churchyards were left alone. Some wild yews were over cropped and died. Other wild yews were removed when livestock was put into fields where they grew. That is why large venerable yews are almost always found in churchyards today. Looking at place and field names with the yew element - only 6% are near churches so it is a false assumptuion to believe that they were always associated with churches and pagan sites etc.

Oldest yews that I know of are three in Powys - Defynnog, Discoed and Llanfaredd. All exceed 35 feet in girth giving an estimated age of 4,500 years. Yews do not have a single trunk so it is not possible to establih age by counting tree rings.
Source : Flora Britannica

stop making silly statements, and put down facts. i just know a bit bout the subject as i work with yews on almost a daily basis!

and of course its hard to pull a 60-90lb draw on a 6ft yew bow, but most archers would have been raised practising.

i'm only stating facts, so dont take it personal.

sometimes contributors on this forum maybe should spend time cluing themselves up on such things before answering, and that goes for not just you.
whats that saying, "a little knowledge"....