Steven Pinker has an interesting theory in a couple of his books, particularly 'The Blank Slate'. His claim is that people in the humanities (including archaeology but in particular anthropology) tend to be more left/liberal and are slow to recognise or even flat out deny that prehistory was violent and chaotic. He cites instances of where funding for excavations or publications were threatened unless defensive features or evidence of conflict were re-interpreted as ritual or more non-descript features.

According to his theory, people on the left and on the right have two very different origin stories. The right/conservatives generally subscribe to what he calls the 'Tragic Vision', people are, and always have been, born with flaws and selfish motives that society has to counter with strict traditions, strong institutions and socialisation that values restraint and public duty.

The left/liberals have a different origin story, which he calls the 'Utopian Vision'. According to this view people are naturally born good and selfless, it is modern society and the inequalities of civilisation that are the cause of violence and social problems. Traditions, institutions and religions are actually the problem, not the solution.

Obviously, if Pinker is right, progressives that lean left will be slow to accept that violence could be as old as the most simple human groups. It doesn't fit with the story of violence and social problems arriving only after inequality, organised religions and exploitation become rigid and inescapable.

I think maybe as post-modern thought has seeped in to the general consciousness this is beginning to be less relevant in actually interpreting the past, if society can take any form and patterns of development or theories of evolving cultures are rejected outright then it matters less what was actually going on in the past.

CianMcLiam wrote:
Steven Pinker has an interesting theory in a couple of his books, particularly 'The Blank Slate'. His claim is that people in the humanities (including archaeology but in particular anthropology) tend to be more left/liberal and are slow to recognise or even flat out deny that prehistory was violent and chaotic. He cites instances of where funding for excavations or publications were threatened unless defensive features or evidence of conflict were re-interpreted as ritual or more non-descript features.

According to his theory, people on the left and on the right have two very different origin stories. The right/conservatives generally subscribe to what he calls the 'Tragic Vision', people are, and always have been, born with flaws and selfish motives that society has to counter with strict traditions, strong institutions and socialisation that values restraint and public duty.

The left/liberals have a different origin story, which he calls the 'Utopian Vision'. According to this view people are naturally born good and selfless, it is modern society and the inequalities of civilisation that are the cause of violence and social problems. Traditions, institutions and religions are actually the problem, not the solution.

Obviously, if Pinker is right, progressives that lean left will be slow to accept that violence could be as old as the most simple human groups. It doesn't fit with the story of violence and social problems arriving only after inequality, organised religions and exploitation become rigid and inescapable.

I think maybe as post-modern thought has seeped in to the general consciousness this is beginning to be less relevant in actually interpreting the past, if society can take any form and patterns of development or theories of evolving cultures are rejected outright then it matters less what was actually going on in the past.

Rousseau has a lot to answer for .

The influence of Marxism on one of our greatest archaeologists , Childe , still impacts today . Even his terminology for the period was telling , " Neolithic revolution " . Foragers had to be egalitarian with no hierarchies but interpersonal violence was conveniently ignored , admittedly the evidence was scant but the wishful thinking was still there .

Is Pomo losing it's grip ? We might be past the hey day of Foucault and and even Derrida in the bibliographies but Bourdieu and Lefebvre are hanging in there .

Does Pinker mention Lakoff and Johnson ?
They have a left /right binary suggestion for metaphorical thinking that's similar , ( maybe it's just Lakoff ).

I found this a very interesting read Cian, even though I am not familiar with the work of Steven Pinker. It seems he is saying that people with the similar world views i.e. left = non-violence/peace and right = aggression/force have superimposed those views onto prehistory.
What was going on at the Tomb of the Eagles I wonder ...
http://www.orkneyjar.com/archaeology/2011/03/16/tomb-of-the-eagles-remains-paint-a-darker-picture-of-neolithic-orkney/
There must have been violent individuals who beat their women and children for no better reason than they could - just as there are today. That doesn't answer the enigma of why the skulls found in the Tomb of the Eagles indicate they had all suffered violence either in death or in life before they died. Perhaps they were slaves/captives whose lives meant little to their captors.
Edit: Thinking about it, the slaves theory wouldn't sit with the apparent importance of the burial site so still a puzzle!!