Are there any confirmed in England? How can you ID them as genuine, not natural? I have found about ten on the gritstone around Sheffield this year, and am very reluctant to claim them as being TMA worthy, but the thought nags..all about six inches across. I have also found one instance of two side by side..I photograph and move on. I have looked for cupmarks on one hell of a lot of stones, and gritstone doesn't appear to be any way near prone to pockmarking as limestone. I cannot help but wonder if bullaun stones are a purely Scottish (Irish too? Pass). When you find one on the highest point of a hill you can be, I hope, forgiven for wondering. Thoughts and info welcomed.

Lots of single cup marks have been recorded in England by experienced competent researchers . Recognition is mainly due to experience i.e. recognising genuine examples and being aware of the natural markings associated with the particular geology the markings are on . Grit , like most the surfaces most often chosen for engraving certainly has plenty of the latter . In the case of single cup marks it is not always possible to be absolutely sure , particularly if there are no other markings in the area , and they most probably would be considered “possible “ .
Judging a single cup mark from an image is not ideal but it wouldn’t do any harm to post some pics .

You do find cups/markings on limestone but they are uncommon .

The vast majority of marked rocks are not found at the top of hills , if anything , it would be the least likely point to find them , although they might be found on the slightly higher point in the local topography i.e. top of a knowe / knoll etc .