moss wrote:
What I find abhorrent, apart from nationalism, is the need to form a fake identity and rely on a past history to justify living in the 'new world'. This 'Anglo-Celticism' has also been discussed in the wiki below.... Expect it is just 'westerners' arrogance at work again.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Celtic_Australians

I don't want to get into an argy-bargy about this because I really don't care about it that much one way or the other. I don't 'get' your comment though Moss - we know people from Ireland, Wales and England were deported to Australia for minor crimes (such as stealing food when starving). I don't know about Scottish deportations but I do know many Scottish people went there too. That's before the mass emigration of the 20th Century started. So why is it anymore 'fake' for present day Australians to try and connect with their ancestry than it is for say - 'King Arthur Pendragon' who feels a personal connection with Stonehenge through his 'druid ancestors'.

The aesthetic value of newly hewn standing stones is really a matter of taste - I recall feeling a bit out sorts about the new stone circle erected by the owner of Lush down in Dorset (on private land) a few years back.

Perhaps we could add these Australian stones to the thread you started a while ago.
http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/forum/?thread=74799

M moss

tjj wrote:
I don't want to get into an argy-bargy about this because I really don't care about it that much one way or the other. I don't 'get' your comment though Moss - we know people from Ireland, Wales and England were deported to Australia for minor crimes (such as stealing food when starving). I don't know about Scottish deportations but I do know many Scottish people went there too. That's before the mass emigration of the 20th Century started. So why is it anymore 'fake' for present day Australians to try and connect with their ancestry than it is for say - 'King Arthur Pendragon' who feels a personal connection with Stonehenge through his 'druid ancestors'.

The aesthetic value of newly hewn standing stones is really a matter of taste - I recall feeling a bit out sorts about the new stone circle erected by the owner of Lush down in Dorset (on private land) a few years back.

Perhaps we could add these Australian stones to the thread you started a while ago.
http://www.themodernantiquarian.com/forum/?thread=74799

Where to start.. it feels wrong to transport a 'made up' part of British history to a country thousands of miles away when there is already, through the 'First Nation' a real history, which is often abused by the incomers, see this...

http://www.abc.net.au/pm/content/2016/s4474398.htm
where Aboriginal burials are destroyed.

I suspect that if someone had just built a replica Stonehenge for fun I would not have a problem, but by the fact that it now stands for a 'Celtic' movement in Australia is a bit worrying, it exaggerates differences which to my mind is always wrong.
But of course it will always be a tourists pull ;)

Ooh no argy-bargy, June. Just a difference of perception. I think it's interesting and I'm glad you posted it so it's up for discussion.

I don't mind if people do feel they've got some spiritual? ancestral connection with 'Celtic' roots, with a name like mine I've no doubt got more than a touch of it myself. But what gives me a bad taste in the mouth is the touristy marketing of it, pay to come and see a load of stones in a field. Standing stones come from a time thousands of years before "Celtic" knotwork and bagpipes and personalised tartan, and women at spinning wheels with big black hats on eating Welshcakes, and lucky shamrocks. It's the whole conflation of this nebulous celtic thing boiled down into Stones, as though the Victorian criminals and their minders had some Noble connection with this misty mystical stone-filled past. But actually the original stones are nothing to do with all that 'celtic' stuff at all. So the purveyors of tickets want you to make this spurious connection of mystical nobility with the poor devils that got shipped out to Australia and had to bloody get on with it or die.

I don't know. For me, it's also that the whole field looks full of stones, just one would be more dignified, if the intention is genuinely to be a memorial to the 'founders'. But I think it's just a tourist attraction. So more is more.

sorry to be such a griper :)