nigelswift wrote:
dee wrote:
I reckon that dowsers/mystics whatever tend to get carried away and end up bending 'truth' to fit their theories
They only get "carried away" (and do a lot worse than bending the truth) when "evidence" is requested.

It has often been said that pushing back against repeated assertions of belief of that nature is somehow impolite forum behaviour. As to that, I wonder if this forum would be any use at all if we had a couple of unchallenged resident creationists and everyone else listened unquestioningly?

I applaud your above comments Nigel. I have learnt so much from people like Tiompan, yourself and many others. They are mostly all grounded in accurate knowledge and sensible questions - this is not me being a flatterer as any long term contributors will know I used to sail in rough waters where this forum is concerned.

Just as an aside, I was recently at planning meeting where a developer wanted to get people on side about using an ancient piece of parkland in the Old Town part of town for car parking. This is in order to facilitate an upmarket entertainment 'hub'. I found I was lone voice in my objections and you could say I behaved badly - speaking when I should have been quiet etc. I eventually made a grand gesture and walked out making a parting shot about fighting any planning application as I left. What I didn't know is a local reporter was present and my input made into the local paper. And do you know what, I thank TMA for being able to do that, because this where I honed any argumentative skills I possess - the trick is knowing when to leave the room :)

I'll take your complement but I should point out that George is the one for accurate knowledge as we've all seen and benefitted from for many years.

Glad you made a mark in the papers. Grass roots are needed more and more as the Govt takes an ever tighter stranglehold on the countryside on behalf of their developer mates. (Look at bloody Oswestry). Even the National Trust has been compromised by them (look at bloody Stonehenge). The Campaign to Protect Rural England and amateurs like us are all that's left.

(Incidentally, the Journal had a rare coup, a bit of proper people power, beyond looking like permanent moaners the other day, which was refreshing. Extensive quoting of an important point we made in the paper and EH trying unsuccessfully to say all is well and telegraphing it wasn't! http://www.westerndailypress.co.uk/English-Heritage-deny-claims-coach-park-plans/story-29272782-detail/story.html )

Bravo, June!!! excellent work.

That's brilliant. And if you've found the "when the leave the room" formula, perhaps it would be worth bottling and selling on here :)