tiompan wrote:
Moss , I took your recommendation and had a look at the Stonehenge vid but being laughed out it was only annoying and no longer funny . In the space of less couple of minutes the nonsense was up there with the best ,but this was given as facts not opinion .Any Stonehenge guide would have been highly amused or angry .There is just so much that is plain wrong in it .

Starting at 10 :13 did she really say “Cornish “ Bluestone ? I’m not sure but wouldn’t be surprised .
Talking of stone 68 with the groove “Colonel Hawley excavated this in the 1920’s and later Prof Atkinson in the 1950’s “ No they didn’t . Gowland got the closest in 1901 ,she didn’t even mention him .
“They found it’s partner “. No they didn’t , Gowland was aware of stone 66 but it was Newall who did a minor excavation in situ and it is not adjoining Stone 68.

10:37 “They didn’t understand why , because this is on the axis line of the to the midwinter sunset ,and It would have obscured the sun set ,which archaeoastronomers talk about , So they buried it and it’s here ,where I’m stood , the partner is beneath my feet “Says she moving a couple of metres in the wrong direction . To get from Stone 68 (the one with the groove) to Stone 66 (the buried one with the tongue ) in a direct line would entail clambering over Stone 67 Stone 156 and Stone 55b in the opposite direction to which she went .
“
10 :55 So anything that doesn’t fit into the model of Stonehenge , they buried it . “ Stone 66 the one with the tongue , lies beneath stone 55 this is why it is “buried” ,archaeologists didn’t bury it ,as she suggests .

Then at 11:19 “The first architect ever ,in 1620 to come here was James the First said there were six ( trilithons ) “ James was not an architect and never said anything about six trilithons ,he had simply visited the monument. Even the commission for the survey may have came from George Herbert rather than James .Inigo Jones’ survey included stones that were fallen as erect and an imposition of what he believed to be a Roman symmetry that was not present but led to him including the addition of a sixth trilithon .

By all means speculate and expect some response but that is just all wrong .That is not explaining , it's just fantasy rubbish .
Imagine going through the whole hour , I couldn't handle it .

Tiompan I admire your attention to detail but to be truthful it sinks through my mind and is forgotten, as is the Stonehenge video. I love my world as it is, and the stones as they are. Speculation and theories abound so I keep my cynical hat on at all times, but what I would love to see on this forum is a lot more tolerance and love. X

I must agree with you, Moss, about the need for tolerance. And that's not saying we have to accept that everything's equally valid or right, you know I would say it's an essential ability to be able to critically evaluate things presented as fact. Particularly in a subject area which attracts so many interpretations, shall we say. Critical thinking ought to be taught in schools (but I imagine it isn't because it might cause unrest, get back to your grammar exercises).

But once the issues with what other people are saying, have been pointed out, haven't you done your job? Isn't it then time for the others to assess their position... and if they don't change their minds - well if you keep on getting wound up it's only affecting your own state of mind, and is that worth it? Surely it's better to let it go (like I try to with all the inane advertising one sits through on the tv) and Let Them Get On With It, as my father says.

There was a post on here recently and it did have some unorthodox ideas in it and I couldn't think of anything sensible or encouraging to say about them, so I didn't say anything. But actually, that person was still getting out there exploring their environment and their heritage, and so what if I think their conclusions may have been piffle. We would actually have much in common from our similar passions for old stones, and the need to protect them. And that's probably more important when you come down to it??

ah I'm just getting soft aren't I

Moss ,

Facts have their uses , but misleading punters with nonsense doesn't .
Critical thinking is even more useful .


If someone said "Romans built Stonehenge cos the locals were incapable " , I wonder what the response would be .


I don't think pointing out these problems is being intolerant ,and I only did so in the Stonehenge clip because it was being highlighted . The comments I highlighted were given as facts not opinions .

Btw , do you know who the "guide" was ?