I understand only too well George.You are the one who is being a bit slow here. You have been asked repeatedly to give up your method for scrutiny. You have completely failed to do that, even coming up with some idiotic challenge to divert attention away from this. It seems to me George, that getting a figure off someone else, proposing a figure of your own that's slightly different, and then bluffing it out that your figure is the correct one, with no justification in the way of proof regarding just how you came by that figure, is a tactic that you have used for quite a while now. Most genuine people will only play that game for a while before realising that you are not interested in proving anything but how superior you are. That's why they give up, because its just not that important to them.
So, in light of your method being nothing but bluff, you would have gladly have impressed everyone with it by now if it wasn't, I will give you your chance to prove otherwise. I will give you the grid reference, you work out the necessary, you post your answer, with the full method you used to come to that answer, including the method you use to find the altitude. Not just the formula, the whole method, in a form that can be scrutinised properly, and fairly( not a word you subscribe to)
I will give you a tolerance of 2 degrees, and a timescale of a week, this week in fact. I have measured and photographed the necessary sunrise for you, today. I will post all the details on TMA just as soon as you have posted yours.
There you have it. Get out of that one.
So, in light of your method being nothing but bluff, you would have gladly have impressed everyone with it by now if it wasn't, I will give you your chance to prove otherwise. I will give you the grid reference, you work out the necessary, you post your answer, with the full method you used to come to that answer, including the method you use to find the altitude. Not just the formula, the whole method, in a form that can be scrutinised properly, and fairly( not a word you subscribe to)
I will give you a tolerance of 2 degrees, and a timescale of a week, this week in fact. I have measured and photographed the necessary sunrise for you, today. I will post all the details on TMA just as soon as you have posted yours.
There you have it. Get out of that one.
Maybe a coronation st trumpet, where everybody nips off to put the kettle on.
If this exchange is ever dramatised, who do you want to play you cerrig?
(Bear in mind the bloke who plays Norris is probably busy)
"I have measured and photographed the necessary sunrise for you, today."
Ummm, as a Fair Test setter of considerable seniority may I suggest substituting "I" with "someone else" and "today" with "a day next week"?
What an arse you are .
How many times does it take before you understand that I have explained how to do it and there are countless examples in the litertature .
I'll just not tell you , because you are such an arse
You even profess to know how to do it yourself ,which is odd in that you never come up with the goods to show anything that what I have come up with is wrong .
Now you are suggesting that I nick stuff and slightly modify it .
If there are cases where there are more than estimate ,and they areabout right then we might expect some similarities but what about those cases where there have never been any calcs like the Silbury sun roll or the most recent correction of Michell's figures how do you manage to suggest that they might be nicked .Or discovering the problem with the horizons on the "wheretheplace " web site . They were never on the web or in the litertaure .
It's not a matter of feeling superior ,its your inferiority complex that has been apparent for some time and is currently imploding .
You were challenged to back up your claims ,for the umpteenth time here it is yet again .
"What I will gladly do for you ,is take a bet ,you suggest a site and I will tell you where the sun will rise or set as seen from the site or the alt ,to the same tolerance as is usually expected from astro calc. A referee can hold the £100 and check the test ."
Put your money where your mouth is .
Unless otherwise stated, the copyright in each work is the property of the respective contributor. For usage or questions, contact [email protected].