John Michell lecture

close
more_vert
tiompan T
tiompan May 13, 2016 15:56:02
Replying to cerrig

cerrig wrote:
You see George, once again, you are the one who doesn't get it. Data gathered on site will always be better. Without it you are stuffed. You can put up any figures you like and say they are right, but just how can that be scrutinised without the method that arrived at that figure. You are the one who is constantly ducking this issue.
You don't have all the relevant information, on my back garden, or on John Michell, or any of the other topics you choose to deride. If you were any more one eyed you'd be a pirate.
I accept cash if that's better for you?
Are you really so thick as not to realise that you can't give the details for a site if you don't know what or where the site is ?

What is it you didn't understand about "What I will gladly do for you ,is take a bet ,you suggest a site and I will tell you where the sun will rise or set as seen from the site or the alt ,to the same tolerance as is usually expected from astro calc. A referee can hold the £100 and check the test .
Lets see if you can put your money where your mouth is ,or willing to accept real tests ."
Re-read that until it sinks in .
It's very simple , and you are simply avoiding coming up with the goods as always .

I have the relevant information to show that Michell was wrong .


Anyone can put up figures ,if they are wrong they can shown to be wrong .
I have done that and had them confirmed ,often enough .
You provide nothing , either as original data or anything refuting other data .
Plenty wind though .

Put your money where your mouth is .

C cerrig
cerrig May 14, 2016 12:14:56
Replying to tiompan

I see what you mean about that name calling George, most unseemly and undignified. You should know better than get into an argument with an idiot. Welcome to my level.

You are the one who is being thick George, but as usual you are too fond of your own opinion to see it, or the point I have been making all along.
Your calculations, which are estimates, are only as good as the information that goes into them. All manner of allowances have to be taken into account in order to come up with a final estimate. These allowances are themselves estimates. Where do you go for your estimates.
You don't have all the relevant information , and I'm not going to give it to you. Keep your money George, I don't want it.