nigelswift wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Lubin wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Don't talk to me like that, i'm not 'moaning from the sidelines'.
What are you doing then? I don't post on here now , and only look in occasionally as I got fed up with moaning and backbiting. There were a lot of good contributors on here who put an opinion forward only to be attacked , for want of a better word , by two or three members , and you know who you are , who didn't agree with what they were saying. Just because their opinion ,or belief , is different to someone else's doesn't mean it is wrong or needs to be challenged.

That's all I have to say on the subject.

As I said above I haven't contributed for a long time but after seeing this post I need ed to say something.

The only people I have ever seriously argued with on here are those who tell us all that they KNOW they are correct about their quite fantastic claims but fail to provide one ounce of evidence.

I've never had a problem with people believing in anything, I think all sorts of belief systems are very helpful to all sorts of different people. But when people say things like "Glastonbury IS a chakra", I am just as entitled to ask for proof.

Or Bladup, who I think is clever, funny, a genuinely decent person. Doesn't mean I won't argue about, say, rock art with him if he makes a spectacular claim.
If somebody says they 'believe' then fine, but when somebody says they 'know' it's different.
Imagine a forum where everybody accepted any wild claim. What would be he point of it?
You wouldn't accept it if I said that I KNOW that everybody who lives within 500 metres of the sea is imbued with magical powers, would you? But they are, you know.
I'm with you on this. "I believe" is fine. "It is" is fine too, but only if "where's your evidence?" is an allowable response and not represented as somehow aggressive. Simple as.

Incidentally, it is "it is" type posts drive people away, not the "where's the evidence" ones, as illustrated this very day over the hill ..... http://www.megalithic.co.uk/modules.php?op=modload&name=Forum&file=viewtopic&topic=6956&forum=4

The thing I cannot get my head around, is that if such and such claim is true, why not just prove it? It's so bloody simple.

Evergreen Dazed wrote:
nigelswift wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Lubin wrote:
Evergreen Dazed wrote:
Don't talk to me like that, i'm not 'moaning from the sidelines'.
What are you doing then? I don't post on here now , and only look in occasionally as I got fed up with moaning and backbiting. There were a lot of good contributors on here who put an opinion forward only to be attacked , for want of a better word , by two or three members , and you know who you are , who didn't agree with what they were saying. Just because their opinion ,or belief , is different to someone else's doesn't mean it is wrong or needs to be challenged.

That's all I have to say on the subject.

As I said above I haven't contributed for a long time but after seeing this post I need ed to say something.

The only people I have ever seriously argued with on here are those who tell us all that they KNOW they are correct about their quite fantastic claims but fail to provide one ounce of evidence.

I've never had a problem with people believing in anything, I think all sorts of belief systems are very helpful to all sorts of different people. But when people say things like "Glastonbury IS a chakra", I am just as entitled to ask for proof.

Or Bladup, who I think is clever, funny, a genuinely decent person. Doesn't mean I won't argue about, say, rock art with him if he makes a spectacular claim.
If somebody says they 'believe' then fine, but when somebody says they 'know' it's different.
Imagine a forum where everybody accepted any wild claim. What would be he point of it?
You wouldn't accept it if I said that I KNOW that everybody who lives within 500 metres of the sea is imbued with magical powers, would you? But they are, you know.
I'm with you on this. "I believe" is fine. "It is" is fine too, but only if "where's your evidence?" is an allowable response and not represented as somehow aggressive. Simple as.

Incidentally, it is "it is" type posts drive people away, not the "where's the evidence" ones, as illustrated this very day over the hill ..... http://www.megalithic.co.uk/modules.php?op=modload&name=Forum&file=viewtopic&topic=6956&forum=4

The thing I cannot get my head around, is that if such and such claim is true, why not just prove it? It's so bloody simple.
If the answer is "I can't prove it, i'm not sure it's even real, but I just like doing such & such and believing such & such" then fine! No problem at all, and more power to yr elbow etc.