tiompan wrote:
GLADMAN wrote:
tiompan wrote:
The main point is related to "alignments " .

In the case of the view of Pen y Fan , it is seen from two of the three monuments and unsighted from the other .Does that suggest that it was important to be seen or not ,or did it just not matter ? I doubt that you could make much of a judgement from that evidence . But surely if it was important to be seen then the builders of the monument would have managed it . Further ,it could be seen from other parts of the area apart from where the monuments are sited . The fallen menhir and SE circle are 230 metres apart , go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF.

Not sure this is translating to what can actually be seen on the ground, to be honest. Moving east toward the Nant Tarw and cairn Foel Darw progressively obscures the view through the col until, upon reaching the cairn, it is found to be completely unsighted. So really not sure where else the NW circle could've been placed to achieve the perfect framing of Pen y Fan in the col it possesses... rather than where it is. Placing the circles further toward the col would've rendered them both unsighted, moving them back would've opened up the view, made it not so specific. Perhaps it was accidental? However the fact is that, despite having walked the South Walian mountains for some 30 years, seeing Pen y Fan perfectly framed in the col from the NW circle made a real impact on me because it really was not expected. A piece of theatre.... which is exactly what I look for relating to monument placement in the landscape. Almost as if the view had been specially created :-)
". go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF. "

Sorry that " east" should have been west across the water course .

Again the point was why have two with the view and one without ?
Was the view/glimpse really important ?

The pamphlet writers found it "intriguing " .

One thing I have noticed with monuments is that that they are often sited not far from what would have been , from a moderns perspective , a better or at least wider view .

I said “should “ earlier as I wasn’t 100 % sure , working out long distance viewsheds without access to arcgis is a slow , pretty boring process , but have just done so for a few points on the other side of the water course to the west .
Some of these are not much further from the possible fallen menhir than it is from the SE circle ,i.e. 260 m compared with 230m . The others are up to 2 Km away but it does show that PyF can be seen from a large area close to the monuments .
Some views of Py F are even smaller than from the monuments .
The further west you go , the greater the vista until at points west of the Roman camp and the road Py F occupies about 10 degrees of the horizon .

For anyone interested , I did mention a Welsh stone circle which does reference a peak at a solstice , nobody appears to have noticed the possibility including the astro punters , or at least there are no pics or mention of the event on the web that I have seen .
Looks like a good photo op .No intentionality suggested ,but it does have the added attraction of a reasonableish , for a change , argument for intentionality as it’s biggest stone looks to be in the right place and due to the number of other stones it should be easy enough to line it up to fit the bearing . The hill it is aligned on also a barrow on it’s summit .
There , if the wind didn’t get there first , I’ve told you .

tiompan wrote:
tiompan wrote:
GLADMAN wrote:
tiompan wrote:
The main point is related to "alignments " .

In the case of the view of Pen y Fan , it is seen from two of the three monuments and unsighted from the other .Does that suggest that it was important to be seen or not ,or did it just not matter ? I doubt that you could make much of a judgement from that evidence . But surely if it was important to be seen then the builders of the monument would have managed it . Further ,it could be seen from other parts of the area apart from where the monuments are sited . The fallen menhir and SE circle are 230 metres apart , go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF.

Not sure this is translating to what can actually be seen on the ground, to be honest. Moving east toward the Nant Tarw and cairn Foel Darw progressively obscures the view through the col until, upon reaching the cairn, it is found to be completely unsighted. So really not sure where else the NW circle could've been placed to achieve the perfect framing of Pen y Fan in the col it possesses... rather than where it is. Placing the circles further toward the col would've rendered them both unsighted, moving them back would've opened up the view, made it not so specific. Perhaps it was accidental? However the fact is that, despite having walked the South Walian mountains for some 30 years, seeing Pen y Fan perfectly framed in the col from the NW circle made a real impact on me because it really was not expected. A piece of theatre.... which is exactly what I look for relating to monument placement in the landscape. Almost as if the view had been specially created :-)
". go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF. "

Sorry that " east" should have been west across the water course .

Again the point was why have two with the view and one without ?
Was the view/glimpse really important ?

The pamphlet writers found it "intriguing " .

One thing I have noticed with monuments is that that they are often sited not far from what would have been , from a moderns perspective , a better or at least wider view .

I said “should “ earlier as I wasn’t 100 % sure , working out long distance viewsheds without access to arcgis is a slow , pretty boring process , but have just done so for a few points on the other side of the water course to the west .
Some of these are not much further from the possible fallen menhir than it is from the SE circle ,i.e. 260 m compared with 230m . The others are up to 2 Km away but it does show that PyF can be seen from a large area close to the monuments .
Some views of Py F are even smaller than from the monuments .
The further west you go , the greater the vista until at points west of the Roman camp and the road Py F occupies about 10 degrees of the horizon .
This is simpler and much better , go to http://www.heywhatsthat.com/ . Then "path profiler ", look for "all summits ",then Pen y Fan , it covers the entire viewshed .You can choose how large or small the view depending on the distance , or whether the view is found in big or restricted area .Must be a huge number of monuments in these magenta? areas .