GLADMAN wrote:
tiompan wrote:
Some specific info on the relationship between the three main monuments and landscape features may help clarify some issues .
From both of the stone circles and the fallen menhir/ row the most obvious horizon features are the various summits and cols of Fan Brycheiniog .These occupy about 30 degrees of the horizon . Neither the Sun nor will ever be seen to rise or set over any of that part of that horizon .
The next most obvious horizon feature is the col between Foel Darw and Garn Las which has already been discussed , the sun will be seen to rise there but not at any of the Thom paradigm astro events i.e. Solstices ,equinoxes ,the moon will not rise there at any of the minor or major standstills .
Next is probably the highest point of Foel Darw as seen from the three sites ,again no Sun or lunar alignment belonging to the Thom paradigm is close .
Maybe what is surprising is that that there are there sites and four solstices , two equinoxes , four major standstill and four minor standstill , 42 potential hits and not one on a variety of the most obvious landscape features on the horizon . If the builders wanted to orient their monuments to include alignments on any of the Thom paradigm astro events and include obvious land features ,they didn’t do it ,similarly if it was important to either include or exclude a peep of Pen y Fan they could easily have done so , exclusively , as they did both my guess is that that they were no more concerned with that than the astro horizon connections . It’s not an uncommon story .

When we look at the horizon profiles where the solstices do occur they are on featureless , and in this case relatively flat spots on the horizon . The spot on the horizon for the WSSR alignment is not far from two cairns on Garn Las (150 m ) but they are unsighted from the monuments being on the other ,wrong side of the hill/horizon , and thus could not be considered to be markers .
As with the above this info can be easily confirmed or falsified . There are minor differences between the three monuments and because of this there was no need to calculate all three , so I concentrated on the middle one ,the north west circle . The calc is from (roughly )the centre of the circle .

SSSR : 52 degrees . Horizon spot : SN 82221 26102
WSSR :138 degrees . Horizon spot : SN 82699 24890
WSSS :224 degrees . Horizon spot : SN 80524 24519
SSSS : 312 Degrees . Horizon spot : SN 80885 26778

So we're saying the fact that Pen y Fan is perfectly and solely framed in the col from the NW circle - but nowhere else in the vicinity of the Nant Tarw - was probably pure chance and not intentional. If so it was also inspirational... placement by someone with a natural subconscious flair for sublime appreciation of his (or her?) landscape.
The main point is related to "alignments " .

In the case of the view of Pen y Fan , it is seen from two of the three monuments and unsighted from the other .Does that suggest that it was important to be seen or not ,or did it just not matter ? I doubt that you could make much of a judgement from that evidence . But surely if it was important to be seen then the builders of the monument would have managed it . Further ,it could be seen from other parts of the area apart from where the monuments are sited . The fallen menhir and SE circle are 230 metres apart , go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF.

Alignment is your word George. We started off talking about what could be seen, you brought that in, as usual, and all the other stuff that you like to attack, at the flimsiest excuse. You need some new material butty, because you really are getting very tiresome now. It's impossible to talk to you without you dragging it back around to this. We all know your opinion on "alignments" and "Thom paradigm events", but you keep banging that drum over and over. If you don't believe me, and why would you, you have as good as called me a liar, not for the first time, and again unjustifiably, just go back over these threads and note how many times you mention Alexander Thom in a derogatory manner, at no ones prompting but your own. You are constantly picking arguments with someone who isn't even here anymore. Give it a rest, it's like some sort of a crusade, and it gets really boring.
Apart from that , you are , of course, wrong.

tiompan wrote:
The main point is related to "alignments " .

In the case of the view of Pen y Fan , it is seen from two of the three monuments and unsighted from the other .Does that suggest that it was important to be seen or not ,or did it just not matter ? I doubt that you could make much of a judgement from that evidence . But surely if it was important to be seen then the builders of the monument would have managed it . Further ,it could be seen from other parts of the area apart from where the monuments are sited . The fallen menhir and SE circle are 230 metres apart , go a bit further to the east from the fallen menhir across the water course and the there should be quite a choice of spots with a view of PyF.

Not sure this is translating to what can actually be seen on the ground, to be honest. Moving east toward the Nant Tarw and cairn Foel Darw progressively obscures the view through the col until, upon reaching the cairn, it is found to be completely unsighted. So really not sure where else the NW circle could've been placed to achieve the perfect framing of Pen y Fan in the col it possesses... rather than where it is. Placing the circles further toward the col would've rendered them both unsighted, moving them back would've opened up the view, made it not so specific. Perhaps it was accidental? However the fact is that, despite having walked the South Walian mountains for some 30 years, seeing Pen y Fan perfectly framed in the col from the NW circle made a real impact on me because it really was not expected. A piece of theatre.... which is exactly what I look for relating to monument placement in the landscape. Almost as if the view had been specially created :-)